Former US police officer’s murder verdict reversed in Australian woman’s death

15 September 2021, 17:44

Ex-police officer Mohamed Noor in court
Police Shooting Minneapolis Noor. Picture: PA

Mohamed Noor was convicted of third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter following the death of Justine Ruszczyk Damond.

A US court has reversed the murder conviction of a former Minneapolis police officer who fatally shot an Australian woman in 2017, saying the charge did not fit the circumstances of the case.

Mohamed Noor was convicted of third-degree murder and second-degree manslaughter in the death of Justine Ruszczyk Damond, a dual US-Australian citizen who called emergency services to report a possible sexual assault behind her home.

He was sentenced to 12-and-a-half-years on the murder count but was not sentenced for manslaughter.

The Minnesota Supreme Court ruling means that his murder conviction is overturned and the case will now go back to the district court, where he will be sentenced on the manslaughter count.

We've said from the beginning that this was a tragedy but it wasn't a murder, and now the Supreme Court agrees and recognises that

Caitlinrose Fisher, lawyer working on Noor's appeal

He has already served more than 28 months of his murder sentence.

If sentenced to the likely four years for manslaughter, he could be eligible for supervised release around the end of this year.

Caitlinrose Fisher, one of the lawyers who worked on Noor’s appeal, said she was grateful that the Minnesota Supreme Court had clarified what constituted third-degree murder, and said she hoped it would lead to greater equity and consistency in charging decisions.

“We’ve said from the beginning that this was a tragedy but it wasn’t a murder, and now the Supreme Court agrees and recognises that,” she said.

The ruling could give former Minneapolis officer Derek Chauvin grounds to contest his own third-degree murder conviction in George Floyd’s death in May 2020.

But that would not have much impact on Chauvin as he was also convicted of the more serious count of second-degree murder and is serving 22-and-a-half-years.

(Third-degree murder is) an act eminently dangerous to others and evincing a depraved mind, without regard for human life

State law

Experts say it is unlikely that Chauvin would be successful in appealing his second-degree murder conviction.

The ruling in Noor’s case was also closely watched for its possible impact on three other former Minneapolis officers awaiting trial in Floyd’s death.

Prosecutors had wanted to add charges of aiding and abetting third-degree murder against them, but that is unlikely to happen now.

The trio are due to go on trial in March on charges of aiding and abetting both second-degree murder and manslaughter.

State law has defined third-degree murder as “an act eminently dangerous to others and evincing a depraved mind, without regard for human life”.

A central dispute has been whether “dangerous to others” must be read as plural, or if the fatal act can be directed at a single, specific person.

Ms Fisher argued on appeal that the language required that a defendant’s actions be directed at more than one person, and that the law was meant for cases such as indiscriminate killings.

But prosecutors urged the Minnesota Supreme Court to uphold the third-degree murder conviction, saying that nearly all killings by officers were directed at a specific person.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Virginia Giuffre

Woman driving Prince Andrew accuser Virginia Giuffre during crash that left her with 'four days to live' breaks silence

Exclusive
'Donald Trump has made Putin comfortable,' Mikhail Khodorkovsky has warned

'Trump has made Putin comfortable' despite massive Ukraine war losses, exiled former oligarch tells LBC

The bodies of Andrew Searle and his wife Dawn were discovered by a neighbour.

British couple found dead in south of France home being ‘treated as murder-suicide’

The vehicle was later extinguished after the driver, covered in flames, emerged from the vehicle.

Amsterdam Dam Square car explosion sees driver engulfed in flames - just days after mass stabbing

d

Pictured: US tourist arrested for sailing to remote island and leaving a can of Coke for world's most isolated tribe

The Sentinelese are a pre-Neolithic tribe that rejects contact with the modern world

US tourist arrested for sailing to remote island and leaving a can of Coke for the world's most isolated tribe to try

The Trump administration has been ridiculed after imposing tariffs on uninhabited islands

'No one is safe, not even the penguins': Trump administration ridiculed after imposing tariffs on uninhabited islands

World leaders react to US tariffs

'This is not the act of a friend': World leaders react to Trump's 'unwarranted' tariffs

British couple

British couple found dead in New Zealand named - as police probe possible murder-suicide

Virginia Giuffre said she had been left with 'four days to life' after the crash

Bus driver breaks silence on Virginia Giuffre crash that left her 'with four days to live'

Foreign Secretary David Lammy

David Lammy to urge Nato allies to increase defence spending in bid to make alliance 'stronger, fairer and more lethal'

European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen

EU threatens further countermeasures against US tariffs after 'major blow to world economy'

Lord Sugar labels Trump tariffs 'a disaster' as Apprentice star teases potential US Presidential meeting

Lord Sugar labels Trump tariffs 'a disaster' and warns that the president 'hasn't thought it through'

Buildings that were destroyed during the Israeli ground and air operations in Gaza

Israel expands ground attack on Gaza to seize 'large areas' - despite pleas from hostage families

Police said two people died on Palliser Road, Roseneath.

British couple found dead at home in New Zealand - just months after moving to 'begin new chapter'

Virginia Giuffre warned it was a "very bad situation" after she claimed a school bus ploughed into her car

Virginia Giuffre was charged with breaching restraining order days before crash that 'left her with days to live'