Efforts to draft pandemic treaty falter as countries disagree on future response
24 May 2024, 20:04
In 2021, member countries asked the UN health agency to oversee negotiations to work out how the world might better stop viruses from spreading.
A global treaty to fight pandemics such as Covid-19 is on hold after more than two years of negotiations as countries disagree how the world might respond to the next health emergency.
After Covid-19 triggered once-unthinkable lockdowns, upended economies and killed millions, leaders at the World Health Organisation (WHO) vowed to do better in the future.
In 2021, member countries asked the UN health agency to oversee negotiations to work out how the world might better share scarce resources and stop future viruses from spreading globally.
On Friday, Roland Driece, co-chairman of WHO’s negotiating board for the agreement, acknowledged that countries were unable to come up with a draft.
WHO had hoped a final draft treaty could be agreed on at its yearly meeting of health ministers starting on Monday in Geneva.
“We are not where we hoped we would be when we started this process,” he said, adding that finalising an international agreement on how to respond to a pandemic was critical “for the sake of humanity”.
Mr Driece said the World Health Assembly next week would take up lessons from its work and plot the way forward, urging participants to make “the right decisions to take this process forward” to one day reach a pandemic agreement “because we need it”.
The draft treaty had attempted to address the gap that occurred between Covid-19 vaccines in rich and poorer countries, which WHO director-general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said amounted to “a catastrophic moral failure”.
Addressing a final day of negotiations, the WHO chief insisted: “This is not a failure.
“We will try everything – believing that anything is possible – and make this happen because the world still needs a pandemic treaty,” he said.
“Because many of the challenges that caused a serious impact during Covid-19 still exist.”
The accord’s aim was to set guidelines for how the WHO’s 194 member countries might stop future pandemics and better share resources. But experts warned there were virtually no consequences for countries that do not comply.
The co-chairs of the treaty-drafting process did not specify what caused the logjam, but diplomats have said vast differences remained over sharing of information about pathogens that emerge and the sharing of technologies to fight them.
The latest draft had proposed that WHO should get 20% of the production of pandemic-related products such as tests, treatments and vaccines and urges countries to disclose their deals with private companies.
Earlier this month, US Republican senators wrote to the Biden administration, arguing that the draft treaty focused on issues such as “shredding intellectual property rights” and “supercharging the WHO”. They urged US President Joe Biden not to sign it off.
Britain’s Department of Health said it would only agree to an accord if it adhered to British national interest and sovereignty.
Meanwhile, many developing countries said it is unfair that they might be expected to provide virus samples to help develop vaccines and treatments, but then be unable to afford them.
Precious Matsoso, the fellow co-chair of WHO’s negotiating board for the pandemic treaty, said there was still an opportunity to reach agreement and that efforts would not stop, despite the inability to reach a deal on Friday.
“We will make sure that this happens, because when the next pandemic hits, it will not spare us,” she said.
Mr Tedros, the WHO chief, said there should be no regrets.
“What matters now is when do we learn from this and how can we reset things, recalibrate things, identify the main challenges, and then move on,” he said.
