Jury selection paused in trial of ex-policeman charged over George Floyd death

8 March 2021, 23:44

A demonstrator holds up a Black Lives Matter flag outside the Hennepin County Government Centre in Minneapolis, where the trial of former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin began with jury selection
George Floyd Officer Trial. Picture: PA

An appeal is proceeding over the possible reinstatement of a third-degree murder charge against Derek Chauvin.

The judge overseeing the trial of a former Minneapolis police officer accused over the death of George Floyd has paused jury selection for at least a day while an appeal proceeds over the possible reinstatement of a third-degree murder charge.

As hundreds of protesters gathered outside the courthouse to call for the conviction of Derek Chauvin, Judge Peter Cahill said he does not have jurisdiction to rule on whether the third-degree murder charge should be reinstated against the former officer while the issue is being challenged.

But he said prosecutors’ arguments that the whole case would be impacted was “tenuous”.

Judge Cahill initially ruled that jury selection would begin as scheduled on Monday, but prosecutors said they would ask the Court of Appeals to intervene, which could put the case on hold, so the judge sent the potential jurors home for the day.

Chauvin is charged with second-degree murder and manslaughter over Mr Floyd’s death.

Legal experts say reinstating the third-degree murder charge would improve the odds of getting a conviction.

Chauvin’s lawyer Eric Nelson said on Monday he would ask the state Supreme Court to review a Court of Appeals decision that ordered Judge Cahill to reconsider the charge.

Former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin
Former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin (Ramsey County Sheriff’s Office via AP)

Jury selection is expected to take at least three weeks, as prosecutors and defence lawyers try to weed out people who may be biased against them.

“You don’t want jurors who are completely blank slates, because that would mean they’re not in tune at all with the world,” Susan Gaertner, a former prosecutor, said.

“But what you want is jurors who can set aside opinions that have formed prior to walking into the courtroom and give both sides a fair hearing.”

Mr Floyd was declared dead on May 25 after Chauvin, who is white, pressed his knee against the handcuffed black man’s neck for about nine minutes, holding his position even after Mr Floyd went limp.

Mr Floyd’s death sparked sometimes violent protests in Minneapolis and beyond, and led to a nationwide reckoning on race.

Demonstrators gather outside the Hennepin County Government Centre in Minneapolis
Demonstrators gather outside the Hennepin County Government Centre in Minneapolis (Jim Mone/AP)

Chauvin and three other officers were fired; the others face an August trial on aiding and abetting charges.

Hundreds of people gathered outside the courthouse as proceedings began, many carrying signs that read: Justice for George Floyd and Convict Killer Cops.

One speaker took a microphone and decried the barricades – concrete barriers topped by chain-link fencing, barbed wire and razor wire – set up around the courthouse.

He also ridiculed talk of the Chauvin trial as “the trial of the century”, saying all the jury needs to do is “do the right thing”.

Then he led the crowd in chants of “The whole world is watching!”

Inside the courtroom, Chauvin, in a blue suit and black mask, followed the proceedings attentively, making notes on a legal pad.

Mr Nelson earlier argued that pre-trial publicity of the case and the subsequent violent unrest in Minneapolis would make it impossible to find an impartial jury in Hennepin County.

But Judge Cahill said last year that moving the trial would probably not cure the problem of a potentially tainted jury pool because “no corner of the state of Minnesota” has been shielded from pre-trial publicity.

Hennepin County Judge Peter Cahill presides over a hearing before jury selection at the Hennepin County Courthouse in Minneapolis, Minnesota
Hennepin County Judge Peter Cahill (Court TV/Pool via AP)

The potential jurors – who must be at least 18, US citizens and residents of Hennepin County – were sent questionnaires to determine how much they have heard about the case and whether they have formed any opinions.

Besides biographical and demographic information, jurors were asked about prior contacts with police, whether they have protested against police brutality and whether they believe the justice system is fair.

Some of the questions get specific, such as how often a potential juror has watched the bystander video of Mr Floyd’s arrest, or whether they carried a sign at a protest and what that sign said.

Mike Brandt, a local defence lawyer, said prosecutors will be likely to seek out jurors who have favourable opinions on the Black Lives Matter movement or might have more outrage over Mr Floyd’s death, while Chauvin’s lawyers would be likely to favour jurors who support the police.

Unlike typical jury selection proceedings, potential jurors will be questioned individually rather than in a group.

The judge, defence lawyer and prosecutors will all get to ask questions.

The defence can object to up to 15 potential jurors without giving a reason; prosecutors can block up to nine without providing a reason.

Either side can object to these peremptory challenges if they believe the sole reason for disqualifying a juror is race or gender.

Demonstrators gather outside the Hennepin County Government Centre in Minneapolis
Demonstrators outside the Hennepin County Government Centre (Jim Mone/AP)

Both sides can also argue to dismiss an unlimited number of jurors “for cause”, meaning they must provide a reason why they believe that juror should not serve.

Those situations can get into some detailed machinations, Mr Brandt said, and it is up to the judge to decide whether a juror stays or goes.

“Sometimes there is some tortured questioning,” he said.

Mr Brandt said that even if a juror says they have had a negative interaction with the police, or a negative opinion about Black Lives Matter, the key will be trying to find out whether they can put those past experiences or opinions aside and be fair.

“We all walk into these with biases. The question is, can you put those biases aside and be fair in this case,” he said.

Jury selection will end after 14 people are picked – 12 jurors who will deliberate the case and two alternates who will not be part of deliberations unless needed.

The jurors will be escorted to the courthouse daily and sequestered during deliberations.

Their names will be kept confidential until further order of the court.

Billy Briggs, who lives just 170 steps from where George Floyd was killed, created and maintains the countdown sign at the gas station on the corner of George Floyd Square in Minneapolis, Minnesota
Billy Briggs created and maintains the countdown sign at the petrol station on the corner of George Floyd Square in Minneapolis (Jeff Wheeler/Star Tribune via AP)

The number of seats in the courtroom has been limited to maintain social distancing due to the Covid-19 pandemic, and seats for jurors have been spaced out.

Like others in the courtroom, jurors will be required to wear masks.

The earliest that opening statements will begin is March 29.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

People watch the speech of Hezbollah leader Hassan Nasrallah as they sit in a cafe

Hezbollah leader says pager attack crossed ‘red line’ as wider war fears mount

Lebanese soldiers and firefighters gather outside a mobile phone shop

What to know about the two waves of deadly explosions that hit Lebanon and Syria

The Lamone river overflows its banks near Bagnacavallo, in the region of Emilia-Romagna, Italy

Floods in central Europe threaten new areas as 1,000 people evacuated in Italy

The remains of the Titan submersible on the floor of the Atlantic Ocean

Mission specialist for Titan sub owner says goal was to ‘make dreams come true’

Denmark's Queen Margrethe

Denmark’s Queen Margrethe, who abdicated this year, in hospital after fall

Police officers patrol during a press tour at the Oktoberfest in Munich, Germany

Oktoberfest tightens security in wake of deadly knife attack in western Germany

Lebanese soldiers stand guard as their comrades prepare to detonate a walkie-talkie that was found at the parking of the American University Hospital in Beirut

Hezbollah attacks Israel with drones as fears of a widening war mount

Bosnian Roman Catholic women pray on the occasion of the feast of the Assumption in Medjugorje, some 75 miles south of the Bosnian capital of Sarajevo, in 2000

Vatican green lights devotion at site where Virgin Mary reportedly appeared

Democratic presidential nominee Vice President Kamala Harris speaks at the Congressional Hispanic Caucus Institute leadership conference

Harris plans livestream with Oprah as Trump to address Israeli-American group

Israel’s Strategy Is Forcing Hezbollah into Tough Decisions

Israel’s Strategy Is Forcing Hezbollah into Tough Decisions

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses an election rally in Srinagar, Indian controlled Kashmir

Modi visits Indian-controlled Kashmir on election campaign amid massive security

Two-month-old baby hippo Moo Deng walks at the Khao Kheow Open Zoo in Chonburi province, Thailand

Thai zoo home to viral baby hippo Moo Deng is patenting the pygmy

Former Nissan Motor Corporation executive Greg Kelly speaks during an interview with The Associated Press in Tokyo

Lawyer for American charged in trial of ex-Nissan chief appeals for ‘justice’

APTOPIX Lebanon Israel Exploding Pagers

Lebanon rocked again by exploding devices as Israel declares new phase of war

Truong My Lan, a real estate tycoon sentenced to death for financial fraud, attends her second trial in Vietnam’s largest fraud case in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam

Real estate tycoon sentenced to death for fraud faces trial on new charges

Chinese authorities inspect the scene of a stabbing at the Shenzhen Japanese School in Shenzhen, China after a 10-year-old Japanese student was attacked by a man

Pupil at Japanese school dies after stabbing in China