Donald Trump’s lawyers ask judge to end civil fraud trial

9 November 2023, 19:14

Donald Trump during his civil fraud trial at New York Supreme Court
Election-2024-Trump-Insurrection-Amendment Michigan. Picture: PA

Mr Trump’s legal team say state lawyers failed to prove he intended to dupe banks and insurers by inflating his wealth on financial statements.

Donald Trump’s lawyers are calling for an immediate end to the New York civil fraud trial that threatens the former US president’s property empire.

Mr Trump’s legal team is arguing that state lawyers failed to prove their client intended to dupe banks, insurers and others by inflating his wealth on financial statements.

Mr Trump’s lawyers sought a directed verdict, asking Judge Arthur Engoron to clear the 2024 Republican frontrunner, his namesake company and other defendants of wrongdoing at the halfway point in the trial of state attorney general Letitia James’s lawsuit.

“There’s no victim. There’s no complainant. There’s no injury. All of that is established now by the evidence,” Mr Trump’s lawyer Christopher Kise said. He argued that state lawyers had failed to meet “any legal standard” to prove allegations of conspiracy, insurance fraud and falsifying business records.

Mr Trump, left, and his lawyer Chris Kise
Mr Trump, left, and his lawyer Chris Kise (Luiz C. Ribeiro/Pool Photo via AP)

State lawyer Kevin Wallace responded that the defence’s arguments “sounded more like closing arguments” and that there was no basis for a directed verdict.

Mr Engoron did not make an immediate decision, saying the arguments were “taken under advisement”. The judge, who has repeatedly ruled against Mr Trump, has signalled interest in seeing the trial to its conclusion, asking defence lawyers for witness schedules and pegging closing arguments close to Christmas.

Mr Kise implored Mr Engoron to give special weight to Mr Trump’s evidence on Monday, citing the ex-president’s decades of experience as a property developer. He argued that Ms James, in pursuit of a political opponent, was trying to “substitute her judgment for that of the banks and, frankly, for that of someone who has been involved in the real estate industry for 50 years”.

In the witness box on Monday, between barbs for his adversaries, Mr Trump denied wrongdoing and said lenders were “extremely happy” doing business with him. If anything, Mr Trump said, his financial statements underestimated his wealth and the value of assets such as his Mar-a-Lago estate in Florida.

Mr Kise said on Thursday, that when talking about property, “if my choices were Donald Trump or attorney general James, respectfully, I would go with Donald Trump”.

New York attorney general Letitia James
New York attorney general Letitia James is seeking the return of what she says is more than 300 million dollars in fraudulent gains (AP Photo/Yuki Iwamura)

Clifford Robert, a lawyer for Mr Trump’s eldest sons Eric and Donald Trump Jr, asked that claims against them should be dismissed. He argued that state lawyers had failed to prove that the sons, whom Mr Trump appointed to run his company when he went to the White House in 2017, worked on the ex-president’s financial statements.

Mr Robert said the sons, who signed off on some documents attesting to their father’s wherewithal, “acted appropriately” in trusting accountants and lawyers for assurance the documents were accurate.

“I’m sorry to say that my clients have been dragged into what is essentially a fight between the attorney general and their father, but here we are,” Mr Robert said. “The time has come that we need to put an end to it.”

Mr Wallace countered that Mr Trump, and his sons each signed documents saying that they were responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of the financial statements, which Mr Engoron has already ruled were false and misleading.

The lawyers were making their arguments in court a day after Mr Trump’s daughter Ivanka Trump gave evidence as the state’s last witness.

Ivanka Trump after giving evidence in the trial
Ivanka Trump after giving evidence in the trial (AP Photo/Ted Shaffrey)

Directed verdict requests are common in civil trials, though they are somewhat infrequently granted. In Mr Trump’s trial, Mr Engoron is tasked with deciding the outcome rather than a jury.

Mr Engoron has repeatedly sided with state lawyers over Mr Trump, most consequentially in a decision before the trial that Mr Trump, his company and other defendants committed fraud by exaggerating his net worth and the value of assets on his financial statements, which were used to obtain loans and make deals.

Mr Engoron’s pre-trial fraud ruling came with provisions that could strip the ex-president of such marquee properties as Trump Tower, though an appeals court is allowing him to remain in control of his holdings for now.

The state rested its case on Wednesday after six weeks of evidence from more than two dozen witnesses. Ms James is seeking the return of what she says is more than 300 million dollars (£245 million) in fraudulent gains and a ban on Mr Trump and other defendants from doing business in New York.

Mr Trump gave evidence on Monday. Eric and Donald Trump Jr gave evidence last week. Trump Organisation executives, outside accountants who worked on Mr Trump’s financial statements and bank executives who worked on his loans also gave evidence.

Mr Kise emphasised that lender Deutsche Bank made its own adjustments to the asset values listed on Mr Trump’s financial statements, giving substantial “haircuts” to the estimates for Trump Tower and other properties, and decided to lend him hundreds of millions of dollars anyway. Adjustments amounted to 2 billion dollars in some years, Mr Kise said.

Mr Kise also attacked Mr Trump’s former lawyer-turned-foe Michael Cohen’s credibility. He said Mr Cohen undermined the state’s case when he backtracked from his initial evidence that Mr Trump had directed him to boost the value of assets to “whatever number Trump told us to”.

Pressed on cross-examination during his evidence on October 25, Mr Cohen conceded that Mr Trump never told him to inflate the numbers on his personal statement. Mr Robert then asked for an immediate directed verdict, which Mr Engoron denied. Mr Kise called Mr Cohen’s evidence a “pathetic performance”.

The sides are spending Thursday making legal arguments known as motions, including the defence’s directed verdict bid. Mr Trump’s side is scheduled to start calling witnesses on Monday, though that would be moot if Mr Engoron ended the trial with a directed verdict.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Near-Earth asteroid, artwork

NASA scientist reveals list of countries that face being hit by huge 'city killer' asteroid the size of Big Ben

This illustrative image shows Russian President Vladimir Putin (left) and United States President Donald Trump (right).

Donald Trump is 'setting preconditions for withdrawing from NATO', his former advisor tells LBC

Naya Rivera

Glee star Naya Rivera's heartbreaking final words to her son before she drowned revealed

The young man was swallowed by a whale

Shocking moment whale swallows kayaker whole before spitting him back out

Deise Moura has been arrested on suspicion of killing her relatives with a poisonous Christmas cake

Woman accused of murder after 'Christmas cake poisoning' that killed three is found dead in prison cell

The bodies of Andrew Searle and his wife Dawn were discovered by a neighbour

Mystery deepens over British couple found dead in France as wife 'made appointments' before deaths

Relatives and supporters of Israeli hostages held in Gaza since the October 7, 2023 attacks, block Ayalon Highway in Tel Aviv during a protest calling for the release of all hostages

Hamas backs down over Israeli hostage deal threat amid fears ceasefire will collapse

The largest of the Chagos islands, Diego Garcia, the site of a joint military facility of the United Kingdom and the United States

US makes last-ditch intervention in Chagos islands negotiations amid concerns China will benefit from deal

Police at the scene after the car crashed into protesters

Afghan asylum seeker arrested after car ploughs into crowd leaving dozens of people injured including children

Emergency services work near the scene of an explosion at a bar where a grenade was thrown, in Grenoble, on February 12, 2025.

At least 12 injured after man wielding assault rifle throws grenade into bar

Italian F1 Grand Prix - Previews

Nightclub bouncer behind £12m plot to reveal Formula One star Michael Schumacher's health secrets jailed

Josef Fritzl

Incest monster Josef Fritzl could walk free from prison next year - and expects 'cheering crowds' to greet him

United States Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, left, shakes hands with Britain's Defense Secretary John Healey prior to a bilateral meeting on the sidelines of a NATO defense ministers meeting at NATO headquarters in Brussels, Wednesday, Feb.

Ukraine's NATO membership plans 'unrealistic' says US - as defence secretary claims US troops won't be peacekeepers

Lucy Harrison

British woman, 23, dies after being shot dead at dad's US house as 'utterly heartbroken' family pays tribute

An asteroid could hit earth in 2036.

NASA makes 'emergency' decision over asteroid the size of Big Ben that could strike Earth

Exclusive
His Royal Highness Prince Khalid bin Bandar Al Saud

No alcohol at all will be allowed at 2034 World Cup, Saudi ambassador tells LBC