US appeals court keeps Michael Flynn case alive and will not order its dismissal

1 September 2020, 16:14

Michael Flynn
Trump Adviser Arrest Glance. Picture: PA

Federal prosecutors moved in May to dismiss the prosecution even though Mr Flynn had pleaded guilty and admitted lying to the FBI.

A federal appeals court has declined to order the dismissal of the prosecution of US President Donald Trump’s former national security adviser Michael Flynn.

The court in Washington has permitted a judge to scrutinise the US Justice Department’s request to dismiss its case against Mr Flynn.

The decision keeps the matter at least temporarily alive and rejects efforts by both Mr Flynn’s lawyers and the Justice Department to force the prosecution to be dropped without any further inquiry from the judge, who has declined to dismiss it for months.

Federal prosecutors moved in May to dismiss the prosecution even though Mr Flynn had pleaded guilty and admitted lying to the FBI during the Russia investigation about his Russian contacts during the presidential transition period. He was awaiting sentencing when the government asked to dismiss the case.

But US district judge Emmet Sullivan, signalling his scepticism at the government’s motion, refused to immediately grant the request and instead appointed a retired federal judge to argue against the Justice Department’s position.

US President Donald Trump
US President Donald Trump (Alex Brandon/PA)

Mr Flynn’s lawyers then sought to bypass Mr Sullivan and obtain a order from the federal appeals court that would have required the judge to immediately force the judge to dismiss the case.

At issue before the court was not the merits of Mr Flynn’s prosecution but rather whether Mr Sullivan could be forced to grant the Justice Department’s dismissal request without even holding a hearing to scrutinise the basis for the motion.

“We have no trouble answering that question in the negative,” the court wrote in an unsigned opinion for the eight judges in the majority.

Mr Flynn was the only person charged in special counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation who had been a White House official. Mr Mueller’s probe investigated ties between the 2016 Trump campaign and Russia.

He was questioned by the FBI at the White House, just days after Mr Trump’s inauguration, about his conversations with the then-Russian ambassador to the US pertaining to sanctions that had just been imposed by the Obama administration for election interference.

The conversation alarmed law enforcement and intelligence officials who were already investigating whether the Trump campaign had co-ordinated with Russia to sway the presidential election in Mr Trump’s favour. They were puzzled by the White House’s public insistence that Mr Flynn and the diplomat had not discussed sanctions.

But the Justice Department argued in May that the FBI had insufficient basis to interrogate Mr Flynn about that conversation, which attorney general William Barr has described as fully appropriate for an incoming national security adviser to have had.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Volodymyr Zelenskyy is set to meet US officials in Saudi Arabia

Zelenskyy vows to 'work constructively' with Trump as US-Ukraine peace talks to go ahead in Saudi Arabia

Rome, Italy. 25th Jan, 2025. Pope Francis seen during the Celebration of Vespers

Pope Francis heard speaking for first time since entering hospital as he thanks well-wishers in audio message

Volodymyr Zelenskyy is set to meet US officials in Saudi Arabia

Zelenskyy to meet US officials in Saudi Arabia, as Trump hits out at NATO allies 'not paying enough'

Port de Sóller

Spanish holiday hotspot introduces 'resident-only' zones - here's how the 'nightmare' policy will impact tourists

Exclusive
Any deal with Russia may take time Ukraine doesn't have, the former PM of Ukraine has warned.

Peace deal with Russia will 'take time' that Ukraine might not have, former Ukrainian PM warns

Ambassador of the Russian Federation to the UK Andrei Kelin

Russia wants a 'quick peace' in Ukraine, ambassador claims as he accuses UK of prolonging war

President Zelenskyy thanked European leaders for their support

'We don't feel alone': Zelenskyy thanks European leaders following emergency defence summit

The brother of Olympic breakdancer Rachel “Raygun” Gunn has been charged after dealing with proceeds from an alleged fraud syndicate

Brother of viral Olympic breakdancer 'Raygun' charged over involvement in $100K crypto fraud

The unnamed French man, identified only as a Parisian in his twenties, is facing a criminal investigation after hurling the ice rock at the elderly man.

WATCH: Moment skier hurls giant snowball from chairlift injuring granddad below- as prankster faces jail

Gisele Pelicot has been criticised by her daughter for not backing her claim that she was also raped by Dominique Pelicot

Ex-wife of ‘Monster of Avignon’ criticised by daughter for abandoning her as fellow victim

President Zelenskyy thanked European leaders for their support

'You stayed with us': Zelenskyy thanks European leaders at emergency defence summit

YouTube star Andrew Cross has died at the age of 36

YouTuber Andrew Cross dies aged 36 after being taken off life support weeks after horror crash

Trump has issued a final warning to Hamas

Trump issues final warning to Hamas: 'Release Israeli hostages now or there will be hell to pay'

US is 'prepared' for war with China

US 'prepared' to go to war with China, says defence secretary amid threat of tariff retaliation

Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, Britain's Prime Minister Keir Starmer and France's President Emmanuel Macron hold a meeting

UK and France to finalise Ukraine peace plan 'in days', as Macron says Europe has 'entered new era'

Trump cuts off intelligence sharing with Ukraine as pressure ramps up ahead of minerals deal

Trump cuts off intelligence sharing with Ukraine as pressure ramps up ahead of minerals deal