Users of smart devices should receive more security information, MPs hear

17 January 2023, 17:54

Smart home control interface with finger touching smart-home assistant button on virtual screen dashboard
Smart home control interface with finger touching smart-home assistant button on virtual screen dashboard. Wireless connection between smart devices,. Picture: PA

A Google representative said products such as virtual assistants should have labels detailing their security and privacy quality.

Users of connected devices should be given more information on security and privacy, MPs have heard.

The Commons Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) Committee is investigating the impact of devices such as smart speakers and wearable tech and what needs to be done to ensure they are safe to use.

A standardised “ingredients label” that explains the security and privacy quality of a product, wherever in the world it was manufactured, would provide better transparency for consumers, a Google representative told the committee on Tuesday.

David Kleidermacher, vice-president of engineering for Android and Made-by-Google Security and Privacy, said: “We have to give consumers the tools to make better decisions.

I fervently hope that in a short period of time we'll be going into the retailer and we'll see not just labels on energy for the television, but also a digital label, an online label that tells you the security quality

David Kleidermacher, Google

“So today, if you’re going to buy a television, you go into the retailer and you can compare things like the screen quality and audio quality.

“But can the consumer actually decide or have any frame of reference for deciding on the security and privacy quality of those products? And I think the answer today is no…

“I fervently hope that in a short period of time we’ll be going into the retailer and we’ll see not just labels on energy for the television, but also a digital label, an online label that tells you the security quality.”

He said that would push manufacturers to start competing on security features.

Mr Kleidermacher agreed with the UK Government’s assessment that cybersecurity tends to be an afterthought for manufacturers, noting that this is “not for malicious reasons”.

While Google is under “constant attack”, including from state sponsors such as China, and therefore has a strong economic incentive to invest in cybersecurity, other companies that have not been targeted are less focused on the issue, he said.

Mr Kleidermacher and Leila Rouhi, Amazon Alexa vice-president of trust and privacy, who both spoke via video link from California, reassured MPs over the safety of their companies’ voice-activated virtual assistants.

Concerns have been raised in the past about user privacy and data collection.

We know that if we have a trust-busting incident like that it would have major ramifications for our business

Leila Rouhi, Amazon Alexa

Ms Rouhi said “there is a common misconception that Alexa is always listening” and added that users can delete any recordings, which may otherwise be used by the company to train speech recognition using machine learning.

She said the tech giant is “incredibly mindful” of the risk of information flowing into the wrong hands, adding: “That is why we invest so heavily in ensuring that that does not happen.

“We know that if we have a trust-busting incident like that it would have major ramifications for our business.”

Apple declined to give evidence to the committee.

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

A child’s hand pressing a key of a laptop keyboard

Charity ‘appalled’ at reports online safety laws could be cut for US trade deal

School children during a Year 5 class at a primary school

Education Secretary: More men needed in classrooms to be positive role models

Games controller

Cult classic Shenmue named most influential game of all time in Bafta poll

Alliance MP Sorcha Eastwood (PA)

Parents crying out for online regulation, MP Eastwood says

TikTok is set to be banned in the United States later this week unless a buyer emerges.

Amazon makes last-minute bid to buy TikTok as deadline looms

Nintendo Switch 2

Everything you need to know about the Nintendo Switch 2

The Nintendo Switch 2 will release on June 5, 2025

Nintendo Switch 2: Exciting reveal, but why is it more expensive here?

A Nintendo Switch 2

Nintendo confirms Switch 2 will launch on June 5

Tesla dealership damage

Tesla sales tumble to weakest since 2022 amid Musk backlash

The Nintendo Switch 2

Nintendo reveals release date for long-awaited Switch 2 console

Roblox has introduced a slew of new safety features.

Gaming platform Roblox adds slew of safety fixtures for parents to monitor their children’s accounts

Meta's decision to change its content policies was heavily criticised by online safety experts (PA)

Majority oppose Meta’s rollback of safety rules, charity says

A child's hands pressing laptop keys

Regulation and technology can help combat spread of online misogyny, expert says

Raspberry Pi 4 micro computer

Raspberry Pi profits tumble after supply shortages

An RNLI lifeboat brings a group of people thought to be migrants into Dover

UK to work with allies and social media to tackle people smuggling adverts

A child using an Apple iPhone smartphone

School curriculum resources to teach children about risks of in-game purchases