Removing face unlock from Pixel smartphones ‘a good trade-off’

15 November 2020, 08:04

Google Pixel 5
Google Pixel 5. Picture: PA

Google decided to go back to a fingerprint sensor on its new 5G Pixel smartphone.

Discontinuing face unlock and reverting back to a fingerprint sensor on the Pixel smartphone is “a good trade-off” to enable other premium features, a Google product manager has said.

The tech giant introduced facial identification to the Pixel 4 device for the first time in 2019 but decided to bring back the fingerprint sensor in this year’s Pixel 5.

Face unlock initially suffered an issue where it would still work when a person’s eyes were closed, though it was later fixed.

Soniya Jobanputra, a product manager on the Pixel team, told the PA news agency that while face unlock was removed it could be repurposed in a different form in the future.

Google's Soniya Jobanputra
Google’s Soniya Jobanputra (Google/PA)

“When we set out on Pixel 5 what we really wanted to accomplish was get you a 5G device that still felt super premium and didn’t feel like you compromised on anything and so what we had to do to accomplish that was literally stack rank what we find users find most useful,” she said.

“We really wanted to maximise that value, that you are getting for every penny that you were paying for that product.

“And as we stack ranked it, you’ll find all the traditional things like the camera is super important and processing and speed. That’s super important and memory is super important.

“And so as we looked at that list face ID is awesome and it’s a great tool for unlocking your device, but you know what, a fingerprint sensor can meet those needs as well, just as efficiently, just as fast and in some cases even more securely and so, we really felt that it was a good trade-off for users to go with the rear fingerprint sensors so that we could enable some of these other premium features that users are looking for in a device.

She continued: “We did a lot of work to bring that technology to life, so hopefully we’ll find a way to repurpose the work that was done in it because I think there’s some wonderful innovations that we have in that feature but it may not come back in the form that that you’ve seen it in the past.”

Google is currently preparing a movie giveaway to promote the speed benefits of 5G on the Pixel and also hopes to offer some entertainment during lockdown.

Users will be able to find the British Film Institute’s most rewatchable British films hidden on Google Maps to watch for free.

Movies will be scattered across Google Maps for users to find later this month
Movies will be scattered across Google Maps for users to find later this month (Google/PA)

“You will be able to go visit our special Google Map on the Mobile Cinema page and you’ll be able to zoom into different locations across Britain,” Ms Jobanputra said.

“Symbolic clues will be left for people to find and we’ll also be adding batches of films every three days according to the genre.

“We’ll be sharing some hints and clues on our Google UK Twitter page to kind of guide people through the process.”

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

Openreach van

Upgrade to Openreach ultrafast full fibre broadband ‘could deliver £66bn boost’

Laptop with a virus warning on the screen

Nato countries are in a ‘hidden cyber war’ with Russia, says Liz Kendall

Pat McFadden

Russia prepared to launch cyber attacks on UK, minister to warn

A person holds an iphone showing the app for Google chrome search engine

Apple and Google ‘should face investigation over mobile browser duopoly’

A Google icon on a smartphone

Firms can use AI to help offset Budget tax hikes, says Google UK boss

Icons of social media apps, including Facebook, Instagram, YouTube and WhatsApp, are displayed on a mobile phone screen

Growing social media app vows to shake up ‘toxic’ status quo

Will Guyatt questions who is responsible for the safety of children online

Are Zuckerberg and Musk responsible for looking after my kids online?

Social media apps on a phone

U16s social media ban punishes children for tech firm failures, charities say

Google shown on a smartphone

US Government proposes forcing Google to sell Chrome to break-up tech empire

The logo for Google's Gemini AI assistant

Google’s Gemini AI gets dedicated iPhone app in the UK for the first time

Facebook stock

EU fines Meta £660m for competition rule breaches over Facebook Marketplace

A phone taking a photo of a phone mast

Government pledges more digital inclusion as rural Wales gets phone mast boost

Social media apps displayed on a mobile phone screen

What is Bluesky and why are people leaving X to sign up?

Someone types at a keyboard

Cyber security chief warns Black Friday shoppers to be alert to scams

MPs

Ministers pressed on excluding Chinese firms from UK’s genomics sector

Child with mobile phone stock

Specially designed smartphone for children launches in the UK