Children ‘no match’ for Silicon Valley billions, peer says in online safety plea

22 January 2025, 10:44

A child uses a tablet computer
Little girl uses a digital tablet. Two-year-old child looks electronic device at home. Cute toddler sits on a couch and plays computer games. Face of. Picture: PA

‘A child whether five or 15 is no match for the billions of dollars spent hijacking their attention’, Baroness Kidron said

A child is “no match for the billions of dollars spent hijacking their attention”, a filmmaker has warned in a plea for strengthened child safety online.

Baroness Kidron, whose credits include Bridget Jones: The Edge Of Reason and Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit, agreed to drop her proposed amendments to the Data (Use and Access) Bill, on the condition that the Government considers future changes to bolster children’s safety online.

The crossbencher proposed several changes to the proposed law, including a new clause which would compel organisations to consider that children are “entitled to a higher standard of protection than adults”.

Public trust in both tech and politics is catastrophically low and while we may disagree on the extent to which adults deserve privacy and protection, there are few in this House or the other place who do not believe it is a duty of Government to protect children

Baroness Kidron

Lord Vallance of Balham, a technology minister, said the Government was “open to exploring a more targeted approach”.

Baroness Kidron told the Lords: “In the last few weeks, Meta has removed its moderators. The once-lauded Twitter has become flooded with disinformation and abuse as a result of Elon Musk’s determined deregulation and support of untruth.

“We’ve seen the dial move on elections in Romania’s presidential election via TikTok, a rise in scams and the horror of sexually explicit deepfakes that we will discuss in a later group.

“Public trust in both tech and politics is catastrophically low and while we may disagree on the extent to which adults deserve privacy and protection, there are few in this House or the other place who do not believe it is a duty of Government to protect children.”

She added: “The Government has a decision to make. It can choose to please the CEOs of Silicon Valley in the hope of the capitulation on regulatory standards will get us a data centre or two, or it can prioritise the best interests of UK children and agree to these amendments that put children’s needs first.”

Baroness Kidron
Baroness Kidron (Joshua Bratt/PA)

Lord Russell of Liverpool, also an independent crossbencher, said: “What we are trying to do with this set of amendments is upfront. We are trying to say to the Government we want this to be as effective as it possibly could be now and we do not want to come back and rue the consequences of not a) being completely clear and b) putting very, very clear onus of responsibility on the regulators in two or three years’ time because another two or three years of children will have important parts of their childhood deteriorating quite rapidly with consequences that will stay with them for the rest of their lives.”

Lord Vallance said that “requiring all data controllers to identify whether any of the data they hold relates to children and applying a higher standard to it would place a disproportionate burden on small businesses and other organisations that currently have no way of differentiating age groups”.

The minister the Government is “open to exploring a more targeted approach”, putting the emphasis on technology companies.

Baroness Kidron agreed not call a vote but told peers: “A child, whether five or 15, is no match for the billions of dollars spent hijacking their attention, their self-esteem and their bodies, and we have to in these moments as a House choose David over Goliath.”

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

A Barclays sign outside a branch

Barclays to hand share award to staff after yearly profit surges by a quarter

A bin of seized knives. A new AI tool from the University of Surrey has been unveiled which could help police forces more quickly identify and trace knives.

New AI tool to identify knives could ‘transform’ policing of knife crime

Former executive chairman of Google Eric Schmidt

Former Google boss warns of ‘extreme risk’ from terrorists posed by AI

A laptop displaying a ‘Matrix’-style screensaver

MPs: Ministers must give protections to creative sector amid AI copyright fears

French President Emmanuel Macron addresses the audience in a closing speech at the Grand Palais during the Artificial Intelligence Action Summit in Paris

Refusal to sign AI declaration was ‘based on what’s best for British people’

Someone at a computer keyboard

Airbnb issues warning over holiday scams fuelled by AI and social media

An HSBC branch

HSBC online and mobile banking working again after service outage

HSBC on growth across the UK

HSBC hit by outage as users complain of being unable to log on

The summit in Paris (Michel Euler/AP)

UK did not sign AI communique over ‘opportunity and security’ concerns – No 10

Sky Glass Gen 2

Sky unveils second generation Sky Glass TV promising ‘better picture and sound’

Technology Stock

UK announces sanctions against Russian cyber crime network

Participants in the AI Action Summit pose for a group photo at the Grand Palais in Paris

UK appears not to have signed leaders’ declaration at AI summit

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman

Sam Altman reiterates OpenAI ‘not for sale’ after Elon Musk-led bid

A young girl uses the TikTok app on a smartphone.

Data of dead British children may have been deleted, TikTok boss says

Elon Musk

Elon Musk offers $97bn to buy ChatGPT-maker OpenAI

Alesha Dixon (Jordan Pettitt/PA)

Alesha Dixon working ‘super hard’ to stop children having phones