ICO criticises Google over ‘irresponsible’ advertising tracking change

19 December 2024, 15:04

Google has been contacted for comment (PA)
Google logo. Picture: PA

The UK’s data protection regulator has criticised the tech giant over its decision to allow advertisers to ‘fingerprint’ user devices for tracking.

The UK’s data protection regulator has criticised Google over its decision to allow advertisers to use technology to track users which is harder to control or block.

The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) said Google’s decision was “irresponsible” and accused the company of a U-turn, having previously prohibited the use of so-called fingerprinting technology.

Fingerprinting involves collecting pieces of information about a device’s software and hardware which can be combined to uniquely identify a device and its user – and the ICO has warned that this technology is harder to wipe than clearing cookies or site data from a web browser, meaning users could continue to be identified by advertisers.

Organisations seeking to deploy fingerprinting techniques for advertising will need to demonstrate how they are complying with the requirements of data protection law.

Stephen Almond, ICO

The ICO’s intervention comes after the regulator said Google had told firms which use its advertising products that from February 2025, it will no longer prohibit the use of fingerprinting techniques within its ad products.

Stephen Almond, the ICO’s executive director for regulatory risk, said: “Yesterday, Google announced to organisations that use its advertising products, that from 16 February 2025, it will no longer prohibit them from employing fingerprinting techniques.

“Our response is clear: businesses do not have free rein to use fingerprinting as they please. Like all advertising technology, it must be lawfully and transparently deployed – and if it is not, the ICO will act.

“Fingerprinting involves the collection of pieces of information about a device’s software or hardware, which, when combined, can uniquely identify a particular device and user.

“The ICO’s view is that fingerprinting is not a fair means of tracking users online because it is likely to reduce people’s choice and control over how their information is collected. The change to Google’s policy means that fingerprinting could now replace the functions of third-party cookies.

“We think this change is irresponsible.

“Google itself has previously said that fingerprinting does not meet users’ expectations for privacy, as users cannot easily consent to it as they would cookies.

“This in turn means they cannot control how their information is collected. To quote Google’s own position on fingerprinting from 2019: ‘We think this subverts user choice and is wrong’.”

A Google spokesperson said: “We look forward to further discussions with the ICO about this policy change.

“We know that data signals like IP addresses are already commonly used by others in the industry today, and Google has been using IP responsibly to fight fraud for years.

“Privacy enhancing technologies offer new ways for our partners to succeed on emerging platforms like CTV without compromising on user privacy.

“We continue to give users choice whether to receive personalized ads, and will work across the industry to encourage responsible data use.”

Mr Almond said the ICO would continue to engage with Google on the issue, and said the ICO would remind businesses considering using fingerprinting that they must meet data protection law, and in relation to this specific technology this was a “high bar to meet”.

“Organisations seeking to deploy fingerprinting techniques for advertising will need to demonstrate how they are complying with the requirements of data protection law,” he said.

“These include providing users with transparency, securing freely-given consent, ensuring fair processing and upholding information rights such as the right to erasure.”

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

A Barclays sign outside a branch

Barclays to hand share award to staff after yearly profit surges by a quarter

A bin of seized knives. A new AI tool from the University of Surrey has been unveiled which could help police forces more quickly identify and trace knives.

New AI tool to identify knives could ‘transform’ policing of knife crime

Former executive chairman of Google Eric Schmidt

Former Google boss warns of ‘extreme risk’ from terrorists posed by AI

A laptop displaying a ‘Matrix’-style screensaver

MPs: Ministers must give protections to creative sector amid AI copyright fears

French President Emmanuel Macron addresses the audience in a closing speech at the Grand Palais during the Artificial Intelligence Action Summit in Paris

Refusal to sign AI declaration was ‘based on what’s best for British people’

Someone at a computer keyboard

Airbnb issues warning over holiday scams fuelled by AI and social media

An HSBC branch

HSBC online and mobile banking working again after service outage

HSBC on growth across the UK

HSBC hit by outage as users complain of being unable to log on

The summit in Paris (Michel Euler/AP)

UK did not sign AI communique over ‘opportunity and security’ concerns – No 10

Sky Glass Gen 2

Sky unveils second generation Sky Glass TV promising ‘better picture and sound’

Technology Stock

UK announces sanctions against Russian cyber crime network

Participants in the AI Action Summit pose for a group photo at the Grand Palais in Paris

UK appears not to have signed leaders’ declaration at AI summit

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman

Sam Altman reiterates OpenAI ‘not for sale’ after Elon Musk-led bid

A young girl uses the TikTok app on a smartphone.

Data of dead British children may have been deleted, TikTok boss says

Elon Musk

Elon Musk offers $97bn to buy ChatGPT-maker OpenAI

Alesha Dixon (Jordan Pettitt/PA)

Alesha Dixon working ‘super hard’ to stop children having phones