Assessing pupils under exam conditions avoids plagiarism in age of AI – minister

4 August 2023, 00:04

Chat GPT
Chat GPT. Picture: PA

The ‘dangers’ ‘of generative artificial intelligence in education need to be addressed, the schools minister has said.

Assessing students’ work “under examination conditions” would tackle plagiarism concerns following the rise of generative artificial intelligence (AI), the schools minister has suggested.

Nick Gibb said the “dangers” of AI in education need to be addressed alongside the benefits it can bring.

ChatGPT is a form of generative AI that can respond to questions in a human-like manner and understand the context of follow-up queries, much like in human conversations, as well as being able to compose essays if asked – sparking fears it could be used by students to complete assignments.

When asked about AI tools like ChatGPT, Mr Gibb told the PA news agency: “We do need to make sure that we embrace the benefits of AI in education, whether that’s helping teachers mark work and so on.”

He added: “But we also need to beware of the dangers as well, and plagiarism is a serious concern. And one way to avoid plagiarism is to have examinations under examination conditions.”

We need to adapt to new technologies, recognising their benefits as well as any risks and explore the possibilities rather than use them as a justification to stick with and increase the use of traditional exams

Sarah Hannafin, school leaders’ union NAHT

In June, Education Secretary Gillian Keegan launched a call for evidence on how generative AI could be used “in a safe and secure way” in education.

It came after the UK’s major exam boards suggested that schools should make pupils do some of their coursework “in class under direct supervision” amid cheating fears in the context of AI use.

When asked whether traditional pen-and-paper exams are here to stay, Mr Gibb told PA: “There are ways of conducting computer-based tests.

“So for example, the multiplication tables check for Year 4 pupils is done on a computer and AI can’t affect that. It’s in a protected environment and the children have to answer the question.

“And a lot of exam boards and Ofqual are doing a lot of research into using computer-based testing, online testing. You just have to make sure that it is protected from corruption.”

One way to avoid plagiarism is to have examinations under examination conditions

Schools minister Nick Gibb

In March, Ofqual’s chief regulator Jo Saxton said ChatGPT has made traditional examined conditions “more important than ever”.

Speaking to headteachers at a conference, Dr Saxton said she would ask pupils to do their coursework and essays under exam conditions if she was a school leader following the emergence of AI systems.

Sarah Hannafin, head of policy for school leaders’ union NAHT, said: “The assessments for qualifications should be designed and developed to enable all students to access them and demonstrate their knowledge, skills and understanding – that should be the most important consideration.

“Once we have that; then safeguards can be built around it. We need to adapt to new technologies, recognising their benefits as well as any risks and explore the possibilities rather than use them as a justification to stick with and increase the use of traditional exams.”

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

Person in yellow coat using smartphone on a train

Spyware accessing phone audio and cameras for data ‘of use to China’, NCSC warns

A woman’s hands on a laptop keyboard.

Majority of AI firms working on unhelpful ‘generic’ tools, think tank says

Bafta Games Awards 2025

Astro Bot sweeps Bafta Game Awards with five wins

A detailed new scan of the Titanic has revealed the ship's haunting final hours.

Scan reveals Titanic's final hours in ground-breaking discovery

Sabrina Carpenter's Fortnite avatar (Epic Games/PA)

Sabrina Carpenter joins Fortnite universe as Festival icon

The tools mean the accounts of under-16s are heavily restricted by default (Alamy/PA)

Meta expands Instagram parental controls and brings them to Facebook

a biotech start-up has announced the animals had been brought back to life

Dire wolf extinct for 12,500 years 'brought back to life', scientists claim

A server room in a data centre

Energy and tech giants to meet Government over plans to power UK AI

A message on an iPhone in London warning that Apple can no longer offer Advanced Data Protection to its customers in the UK

Home Office loses bid to keep Apple legal challenge private

Metro Bank website

Metro Bank launches AI-powered scam detection tool

Esther Ghey

Brianna Ghey’s mother considers parent of her daughter’s killer ‘a friend’

Molly Russell

Meta and Pinterest understood to have made donations to Molly Russell charity

TikTok is set to be banned in the United States later this week unless a buyer emerges.

Trump grants TikTok another extension, avoiding US ban, as he says deal to sell app is 'very close'

A TikTok logo on a phone

Q&A: Will TikTok be banned in the US this weekend?

TikTok logo on a phone

Trump says TikTok deal ‘very close’ as deadline looms

A child’s hand pressing a key of a laptop keyboard

Charity ‘appalled’ at reports online safety laws could be cut for US trade deal