Winter fuel payment cuts force 100,000 pensioners into poverty - but Starmer says OAPs 'better off under Labour'
19 November 2024, 18:41
Some 100,000 pensioners will be pushed into poverty in 2026 by the government's move to means test the winter fuel payment, according to official figures.
Listen to this article
Loading audio...
Rachel Reeves is limiting the annual payout of up to £300 to people who claim pension credit, in a bid to raise £1.5 billion and shore up the creaking public finances.
The move has been criticised by the Tories and some on the Labour backbenches - and the Scottish Labour party said on Tuesday that they had set out plans to partially reverse it.
Work and Pensions Secretary Liz Kendall revealed the government's assessment of the impact in a letter to MPs, but insisted the figures did not take into account plans to increase the numbers on pension credit.
Meanwhile Keir Starmer said that pensioners would be better off under Labour because the state pension would increase.
Read more: Winter poverty looms as energy prices soar and promises fall short
Former Labour adviser admits that the communication around winter fuel payments was 'suboptimal'
Ms Kendall wrote in her letter: "Means-testing winter fuel payments was not a decision this Government wanted or expected to take. However, we were forced to take difficult decisions to balance the books in light of the £22 billion black hole we inherited.
"Given the dire state of the public finances, it's right that we target support to those who need it most while we continue our work to fix the foundations and stabilise the economy - which is the best way to support pensioners in the long term and is what has allowed us to deliver our commitment to the triple lock."
She said the "modelling does not take into account any impacts of the measures we are taking to increase pension credit take-up and to ensure pensioners get the benefits to which they are entitled".
Sir Keir, speaking at the G20 Summit in Rio de Janeiro, said the figures also failed to take account of the household support fund and warm home discount scheme.
"And of course, on top of that, as we now know, the figure for the increase in state pensions for next year under the triple lock, because we've stabilised the economy, is about £470," he added.
"And therefore pensioners will be better off because we've stabilised the economy."
LBC's oldest listener, 105-year-old Owen Filer, talks about the winter fuel payment cut
Debbie Abrahams, the Labour chairwoman of the Work and Pensions Committee, said: "While we're grateful for the Government's transparency on this, there are some outstanding issues on the specific impact on older or disabled pensioners, and the figures say nothing of those floating just above the poverty line.
"We remain concerned by the impact that restricting winter fuel payments might have on poorer pensioners. We'll be watching the issue closely."
Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said: "Finally the dam breaks and we get to see what Labour have known all along.
"Their winter fuel payment cuts are going to plunge 100,000 pensioners into poverty in the next few years.
"Clearly Keir Starmer feels like that's a price worth paying to make a political point. But I don't think those pensioners would agree with him."
Liberal Democrat Treasury spokeswoman Daisy Cooper said: "Faced with these shocking figures, the Government must step up and do the right thing: finally reverse the winter fuel payment cut."
Unease about the policy has led Scottish Labour to pledge to reinstate the payment for thousands more pensioners if they win the 2026 Holyrood election.
Under the plans, all pensioners would receive the payment initially, but it would be tapered over the years to reflect the income of recipients, with those who are better off receiving less in the longer term.
Party leader Anas Sarwar said: "Scottish Labour will take back this devolved power from the DWP, reinstate the winter fuel payment, and deliver a fairer system to ensure that everyone who needs support gets it."
Sir Keir said it was a "one of the features of devolution" that there could be different policies in parts of the UK.
