Trans children can take puberty blockers if they understand 'consequences' of treatment

1 December 2020, 14:27

Keira Bell has won a landmark case against the the Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust
Keira Bell has won a landmark case against the the Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust. Picture: PA Images
Ewan Quayle

By Ewan Quayle

Trans children are only allowed to take puberty blockers as long as they understand "the immediate and long-term consequences of the treatment" to be able to consent, the High Court has ruled.

The ruling is a victory for those concerned about the impact of the treatment on young people but has disappointed trans campaigners who believe it should be more accessible.

Judges concluded that it is “doubtful” under-16s could understand “the long-term risks and consequences” of the treatment, and that it is “highly unlikely” that children under 13 would be able to give consent.

Keira Bell, who began taking puberty blockers at 16 before "detransitioning", said she is "delighted to see that common sense has prevailed" after winning her case against the Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust.

In the judgment, Dame Victoria Sharp - sitting with Lord Justice Lewis and Mrs Justice Lieven, said their ruling was only on the informed consent of a child or a young person, not whether puberty blockers (PBs) were appropriate themselves.

The judges said: "The court is not deciding on the benefits or disbenefits of treating children with GD (gender dysphoria) with PBs, whether in the long or short term.

"The court has been given a great deal of evidence about the nature of GD and the treatments that may or may not be appropriate. That is not a matter for us.

"The sole legal issue in the case is the circumstances in which a child or young person may be competent to give valid consent to treatment in law and the process by which consent to the treatment is obtained."

Puberty blockers can be used to halt the puberty process in trans kids
Puberty blockers can be used to halt the puberty process in trans kids. Picture: PA Images

It adds to an ongoing debate over how accessible treatment should be for those who wish to have gender reassignment surgery.

Trans children's charity Mermaid labeled the ruling a "devastating blow", describing it as "a potential catastrophe for trans young people across the country"

The organisation's solicitor Lui Asquith told reporters: "This morning's judgment has been an absolutely devastating blow for trans young people across the country.

"We believe very strongly that every young person has the right to make their own decisions about their body and that should not differ because somebody is trans.

"The court today has decided to treat trans young people differently to every other child in the country.

"We believe that we're entering a new era of discrimination, frankly."

Trans campaigners have been fighting to get easier access to treatment
Trans campaigners have been fighting to get easier access to treatment. Picture: PA Images

At a High Court hearing in October, lawyers representing the claimants said there was "a very high likelihood" that children who start taking hormone blockers will later begin taking cross-sex hormones, which they say cause "irreversible changes".

The Tavistock and Portman NHS Trust - as well as University College London Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust and Leeds Teaching Hospital NHS Trust - argued that taking puberty blockers and later cross-sex hormones were entirely separate stages of treatment.

But in its ruling, the High Court said: "It is said therefore the child needs only to understand the implications of taking puberty blockers alone ... in our view this does not reflect the reality.

"The evidence shows that the vast majority of children who take puberty blockers move on to take cross-sex hormones."

The court added that both treatments were "two stages of one clinical pathway and once on that pathway it is extremely rare for a child to get off it".

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Novak Djokovic has appointed Andy Murray as his coach for the Australian Open.

Andy Murray to coach old rival Novak Djokovic at Australian Open after retiring in August

Island nations which are vulnerable to climate change and some African countries have stormed out of COP29 in a row over funding.

Negotiators from climate-vulnerable nations walk out of COP29 in row over funding deals

Putin has said he will fire more of Russia 's new hypersonic missiles at targets in Ukraine

Kremlin warns 'a collision between the nuclear powers' is imminent as West fires missiles into Russia

Coleen Rooney on I'm A Celeb

'Wagatha Christie strikes again': Coleen Rooney uncovers I'm A Celeb secret as she calls out campmates

Chloe Barlow is one of the small business owners who will be affected by the change

'It's a mess': Small businesses hit out at EU red tape set to cost thousands, and say 'government has been no help'

Foreign tourists ride on boat in a river in Vang Vieng

Laos government 'saddened' by deaths of tourists in Vang Vieng which include South London woman

Leading brands are dumping Captain Tom Moore’s daughter Hannah Ingram-Moore

Top brands distance themselves from Captain Tom’s daughter after she cashed in on her father's legacy

Euston station has reopened

Euston station reopens after bomb squad carry out 'controlled explosion'

At least 11 people have been killed and more than 60 injured, Lebanon's health ministry has stated

Huge Israeli air strikes hit residential building in central Beirut, killing at least 11 people

Homebase was waiting on around £5 million of tax rebates before collapsing into administration

Full list of Homebase stores up for sale after chain collapses into administration

Live
Storm Bert has hit the UK

Live: Three dead as Storm Bert claims first victims as two die in car crashed and another is crushed by tree

The late Queen and Donald Trump

Queen Elizabeth found Donald Trump to be 'ignorant and hurtful' after Princess Margaret remark

Storm Bert has begun to make an impact with snow closing roads

Trains, planes and roads in chaos as Storm Bert sweeps UK with 82 mph winds and heavy snow

The Princess of Wales during a visit to Southport Community Centre

Princess Kate invites Southport stabbing survivors to Christmas carol concert after meeting them last month

Former Prime Minister Gordon Brown walks through Downing Street to attend the annual National Service of Remembrance at the Cenotaph

Gordon Brown says he will not support assisted dying bill

Labour will reportedly 'set out plans' to boost military spending

Keir Starmer will 'set out a plan to raise defence spending to 2.5% by Spring' as tensions with Russia rise