Thousands of rail fare prosecutions to be declared void after judge’s ruling

15 August 2024, 11:43 | Updated: 15 August 2024, 11:51

Blurred fast train travelling through countryside, Derbyshire, England, UK
Thousands of rail fare prosecutions are set to be declared void after ruling by a judge. Picture: Alamy

By Flaminia Luck

Thousands of prosecutions for alleged fare evasion brought by train companies are set to be declared void after a judge's ruling.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Four train companies including Northern Rail and Greater Anglia brought prosecutions against thousands of passengers using the single justice procedure (SJP), despite not being permitted to do so.

At a hearing in June, Chief Magistrate Paul Goldspring told Westminster Magistrates' Court he believed the prosecutions were "void" and "probably unlawful", with lawyers for rail companies telling a further hearing last month they were "in agreement" the cases should be quashed.

In a ruling at the same court on Thursday, Judge Goldspring said six "test cases" should be declared a "nullity", so it was "as if as though the proceedings never existed".

Northern Rail logo or trademark, England, UK
Northern Rail apologised for errors that occurred. Picture: Alamy

Giving a summary of his judgment, he said: "Parliament did not envisage these offences being prosecuted through the SJP.

"They should never have been brought through that process. This is, to my mind, a paradigm nullity."

He continued: "I'm satisfied that the correct approach is to declare each of the prosecutions void and a nullity."

The exact number of those affected is currently unknown, with a previous hearing told around 75,000 people could have been prosecuted for fare evasion offences under the SJP.

Judge Goldspring said "the number seems to change every time I ask", but a figure of "over 74,000" is a "best guess at the moment".

Thursday's ruling only affects the six "test cases", with the judge putting in motion plans for the thousands of other prosecutions to be declared void in the same way.

Abellio Greater Anglia class 745 train near Wickham Market railway station, Campsea Ashe, Suffolk, England
Greater Anglia brought prosecutions against thousands of passengers . Picture: Getty

Following his ruling, he said attempts would be made by HM Courts and Tribunals Service, the Department for Transport and the train operating companies to identify those affected in the coming weeks.

He said a list of those affected would aim to be compiled by the end of September, with the cases listed as a "bulk" hearing "by the end of October".

He said: "I will simply list them as a bulk listing, no parties required, and then I will then make a similar direction in relation to all these cases affected, so everybody is in the same position."

The judge said by the end of November, "a team will be out in place to begin the work of recovering the money paid and refund the money to individuals".

Read more: Molly-Mae Hague and Tommy Fury split: Everything we know so far about the break-up that shocked the nation

Read more: Putin’s secret files reveal Russia’s top targets for nuclear strikes on UK

"There are discussions ongoing with all the parties about how that may be paid," he added.

After the hearing, a spokesperson for Northern Rail said: "We welcome the judgment of the Chief Magistrate in court today. We would like to apologise again for the errors that have occurred.

"We will now work with the court to implement today's findings. We are unable to respond to individual inquiries in the meantime.

"Northern remains committed to ensuring that all our customers are treated fairly, which means ensuring all passengers who board our trains have a valid ticket."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Basem Naim, a Hamas leader

Hamas prepared for 'immediate' ceasefire in Gaza but claims Israel has not offered any 'serious proposals' in months

London, UK. 9 October 2023. Shadow Chancellor Rachel Reeves speaking during the Labour Party Conference in Liverpool. Photo credit should read: Matt Crossick/Empics/Alamy Live News

Rachel Reeves to 'rip up financial red tape' with pension 'mega funds' freeing up £80 billion for investment

Labour divided over assisted dying as MP who introduced bill hits out at Health Secretary

Labour divided over assisted dying bill as MP tabling legislation labels Wes Streeting's objections 'disappointing'

Reverend Sue Colman was asked to step back after the Makin Report found her and her husband Jason knew about John Smyth's abuse and failed to act

Mustard heir and Church of England minister wife step back from church roles after damning abuse report

File photo of Broadway Market, where the attack took place

Horror as 'man doused in bleach' in busy Hackney market with manhunt underway and attacker still at loose

Former Met Police officer David Carrick pleads not guilty to string of sex attacks including indecent assault against teen

Former Met Police officer David Carrick pleads not guilty to sex attacks including indecent assault against teen

Jack Bradley took part in the failed ram raid

Moment drug addict in 4x4 rams Tesco superstore in failed bid to steal safe, with terrified staff still inside shop

ZM712, a Boeing Apache AH2 operated by the UK's Army Air Corps, departing from RAF Fairford in Gloucestershire, England after participating in the Royal International Air Tattoo 2024 (RIAT24).

Drunken soldiers caught during Apache cockpit romp spark military safety review

Eva Longoria, a Texas native, has said she is 'done' with the US after Trump's second election win

Eva Longoria reveals she has fled 'dystopian' America as Trump names radical right wing cabinet

Dog-free zones should be introduced to tackle racism, the Welsh government has been told.

Dog-free zones needed in countryside to tackle racism, Welsh government told

A 'major' suspected people smugger has been arrested in Amsterdam

'Major' Turkish supplier of small boats for Channel migrant crossings arrested as 'British FBI' swoop in airport

Clifton Suspension Bridge has quit Elon Musk's X after 15 years on the site.

Clifton suspension bridge dramatically departs from Twitter sparking wave of online jokes

Exclusive
Students take gap years and ‘neglect studies’ as survey suggests Edinburgh rents skyrocketed by nearly two thirds in a year.

Students take gap years and ‘neglect studies’ as survey suggests Edinburgh rents skyrocketed by nearly two thirds in a year

Two Just Stop Oil protesters charged over June's incident

Two Just Stop Oil activists charged after orange paint thrown over Stonehenge

Man arrested after reports of person carrying knives outside Houses of Parliament

Man charged with carrying offensive weapons after 'knife' incident near Parliament

Exclusive
Michael Harris died in an e-scooter crash

'My best friend was killed in an e-scooter crash - I'm urging the government not to legalise them for use on roads'