Haunting new footage of Titan sub shows extent of catastrophe, as safety experts explains how vessel came apart

25 September 2024, 17:45 | Updated: 25 September 2024, 17:46

New footage shows wreck of Titan submersible

By Kit Heren

Haunting new video has shown how the extent of the damage to the submersible in the catastrophe that left five people dead.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The Titan submersible imploded in June 2023, on the way to the Titanic shipwreck, killing all passengers on board.

That included Stockton Rush, the CEO of Oceangate, the company that made and owned the sub.

The inquiry into the disaster released new footage of the destroyed submersible on Wednesday.

The wreckage, at 3,776 metres below the waves, lies in ruins on the seabed.

The inquiry heard concerns about the structural integrity and design of the sub on Wednesday.

Read more: Haunting last words from doomed Titan sub revealed as inquiry into OceanGate tragedy begins

Read more: OceanGate boss claimed 'No-one is dying under my watch' after safety concerns were raised over Titan sub

The wreckage of the Titan sub
The wreckage of the Titan sub. Picture: US Coast Guard

Problems included that the sub was cylindrical, when a spherical shape would have been better at withstanding the pressure of deep-sea dives.

In addition, the sole window in the Titan was rated to a depth of 1,300 metres by its manufacturer, but the sub was going down almost three times deeper.

Another problem was that the Titan was made of carbon fibre consisting of layers of resin, which the inquiry heard was unusual for a vessel of this kind.

An expert told the inquiry how there were irregularities in the hull which would have made it less structurally secure on deep-sea dives.

Stockton Rush (left) on board the Titan submersible
Stockton Rush (left) on board the Titan submersible. Picture: Alamy

Dr Don Kramer, an engineer at the National Transportation Safety Board, said that a bang heard as the sub was coming back up from a 2022 dive.

Another issue, according to Dr Kramer, was the places where carbon fibre parts met rings of titanium within the structure, which were particularly weak points.

The inquiry also heard from a man who had gone on a dive in a previous prototype of the Titan, which had left him feeling shaken after he heard a cracking noise.

The Titan submersible
The Titan submersible. Picture: Alamy

Stockton Rush said at the time that it was the vessel shifting in its metal frame, but Dr Kramer said that a change was taking place in the structure of the hull.

Karl Stanley said: "We got down there and it’s making noises - the sound of a carbon fibre bond breaking... We were all clearly a little disnerved.”

He went on: "Then there was kind of like a grand finale of cracking sounds as we were getting close to the surface."

The five crew members onboard the sub were British explorer Hamish Harding, British-Pakistani businessman Shahzada Dawood and his son Suleman, Mr Rush and French deep-sea explorer Paul-Henri Nargeolet (known as “Mr Titanic”).

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Sydney, Australia, August 20th 2023: Spanish Football Federation (RFEF) President Luis Rubiales kisses Jenni Hermoso after Spain win the FIFA Womens World Cup 2023 final football match between Spain and England at Stadium Australia in Sydney, Australia.

'I felt disrespected': Jenni Hermoso tells court she 'never' agreed to kiss from former Spanish soccer chief Luis Rubiales

The Deputy Prime Minister said the government is still facing challenges as they try "to fix the broken system we inherited".

Millions of households facing council tax hike 'beyond normal thresholds' with Labour set to make 'tough decisions' across UK

Ian Airlie, 48, was found dead at his home in Greenwich on October 10

London man, 48, found dead at home after falling down tube escalator was involved in 'very sad and unfortunate accident'

Coercive or controlling behaviour has been placed "on a par" with other domestic abuse offences such as physical violence, as part of a new law aiming to tackle the issue.

Coercive or controlling behaviour now ‘on par’ with domestic abuse in bid to protect abuse victims

Exclusive
The Scottish Animal Welfare Commission (SAWC) has called for a ban on cat ownership

'Cats should be kept indoors', claims PETA following proposed ban on feline pets

Prince Louis has taken this photo of his mother the Princess of Wales

Kate shares new image taken by Prince Louis to mark World Cancer Day

Sir Keir Starmer has said the UK will not be “choosing between” the European Union and the United States

Britain will not choose between EU and US, says Starmer following Trump's tariff threats

Donald Trump won’t impose tariffs on Mexico for another month after a ‘constructive conversation’ which will see Mexico reinforce its side of the border with the US.

US trade tariffs on Mexico paused for a month after border deal

Teachers Fiona Elias (L) and Liz Hopkin (R) were stabbed at the school in Wales.

Girl, 14, found guilty of attempted murder after stabbing two teachers and pupil at school

The school was put on lockdown and a teenages has been arrested after the stabbing.

Boy, 15, dies after stabbing at school in Sheffield - as teenager, 15, arrested

He was travelling back from Tavistock alongside club physio Reighan Taylor when the car sustained a flat tyre.

Former Bournemouth ace fighting for life in coma after horror car crash

Thames Water will seek High Court approval for an emergency £3bn rescue plan

Thames Water seeks High Court approval for emergency cash amid £17bn of debt

By Tuesday a band of rain moves east across England and Wales.

Britain to be battered with heavy downpours and strong winds as band of rain set to sweep through UK

Donald Trump Watches SpaceX Launch Its Sixth Test Flight Of Starship Spacecraft

Donald Trump axes $40billion US foreign aid agency after taking advice from Elon Musk

Idrees Jaff, of Norwich, reportedly attacked the victim at 11pm on June 10 in Chapelfield Gardens

Man, 39, faces jail after raping male victim in late-night attack in city centre park

The school was put on lockdown and a teenages has been arrested after the stabbing.

Stabbing at school gate: 15-year-old teenager arrested as boy, 15, rushed to hospital and classrooms 'locked down’