'There's no such thing as a trans child': Tavistock clinic whistleblower claims doctors have been ‘captured by ideology’

10 April 2024, 18:52

Dr David Bell spoke to LBC's Tom Swarbrick
Dr David Bell spoke to LBC's Tom Swarbrick. Picture: Alamy/LBC

By Emma Soteriou

Tavistock whistleblower David Bell has said "there is no such thing as being born in the wrong body" and the approach of immediately agreeing with a child has caused "considerable damage to generations of children and young people".

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Dr Bell - who was a consultant psychiatrist at the Tavistock Portman NHS Foundation and raised concerns over the trust's gender identity development service - said "affirming a child in what they say is not an appropriate clinical stance".

He said it was "rather shocking" that psychologists and doctors who are trained to put the needs of a child first were so easily captured by a transgender ideology.

It comes after the Cass Review's final report said children have been let down by a lack of research and evidence on medical interventions in gender care, in a debate which it said has become exceptionally toxic.

Dr Bell said he was not surprised by the findings of the report.

Read more: NHS ‘to review all transgender treatment’ after landmark report calls for ‘more cautious approach’ to transitioning

Read more: Trump accuses Biden of ‘assaulting Christianity’ for marking annual transgender event on Easter Sunday

Dr David Bell 'not surprised' by findings of the Cass report

Speaking to LBC's Tom Swarbrick, Dr Bell said: "There is no such thing as being born in the wrong body. There isn't a kind of biological essence of gender that you're born into.

"You're born as your biological sex, and of course, you're the way you identify and your gender is mainly not completely, but it's mainly a constructive socially through your family and the social world that you live in.

"So I think it's right in a way to say there's no such thing as a transgender child in the sense that forecloses.

"Trying to understand a better term is gender dysphoria or gender stress. How this happens is part of a much bigger thing.

"It's not just about the clinic, it's about the it's about the whole culture. It's about the universities.

"It's about private organisations and businesses. The whole world has got invaded by a transgender ideology."

He continued: "The effect on the clinic seems to be part of that. But it is rather shocking.

"I agree with you that psychologists and doctors who are trained to put the needs of a child first were so easily captured by this ideology, and that's been the same in many other countries and in many other countries."

Tom Swarbrick says Be Kind Brigade were 'seduced' by the language of 'being born in the wrong body'

Responding to the report's findings, Prime Minister Rishi Sunak earlier said: "The wellbeing and health of children must come first."

Among the 32 recommendations in the near-400 page report, the independent review of gender identity services for children and young people said a "follow-through service" should be put in place for 17-25-year-olds, with regional centres either extending the age range of their patients or through "linked services".

Responding to the report, NHS England said it had written to local NHS leaders to pause first appointment offers at adult gender clinics to young people before their 18th birthday, and is "bringing forward its systemic review of adult gender services".

In a letter to Dr Cass, officials said that review will now "be undertaken in the context of a broader, systemic review of the operation and delivery of the GDCs (gender dysphoria clinics)".

NHS England said it will provide detail "very soon" but it is understood it will be a Cass-style review led by an independent expert.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

WASPI women demonstrating on Budget Day outside the Houses of Parliament about the lack of compensation n, Westminister, London, UK, October 30 2024.

Waspi women threaten to sue Government over pension compensation package worth £10.5 billion

Torrential rain falls above the taxi rank at Manchester Victoria Station, Manchester, England, UK. 20th February 2025.

'Danger to life' amber weather warning issued as heavy rain and deep floods set to hit UK

Monumental Pharaoh Thutmose II statues in Karnak Temple.

British archaeologist may have found second tomb of mysterious pharaoh just days after major discovery

French forensic police work on the site of a knife attack where a man is suspected of killing one person and seriously wounding two police officers in Mulhouse, eastern France on February 22, 2025.

Four arrested after one killed and several police officers injured in 'terror attack' in France

Long Row, Nottingham.

16-year-old boy arrested after teenager, 17, stabbed in front of shoppers in Nottingham Primark

Pope is 'still in critical condition'

Pope 'still in critical condition' and participated in Holy Mass with carers amid 'complex clinical picture'

Peter Reynolds, 79 and his wife Barbie, 75 have been arrested by the Taliban.

Retired British couple who run education programmes for mothers arrested by Taliban in Afghanistan

Palestinian children and journalists disperse as Israeli tanks enter the Jenin camp for Palestinian refugees in the occupied West Bank, on February 23, 2025.

Israel deploys tanks to Occupied West Bank for first time in two decades as Palestinians 'won't be allowed' to return

The leader of Germany's Conservative party has claimed victory in federal elections, as the far-right AfD party is on track to double their share of votes since 2021.

Conservative leader claims victory in German elections as far-right AfD come second

Jenny Hall

Body found in search for missing 23-year-old runner Jenny Hall

Long Row, Nottingham.

Boy, 17, stabbed in Nottingham Primark

Former defence secretary Penny Mordaunt told LBC that we must invest more in defence to secure peace in Ukraine.

'We have got to wake up' and spend more on defence, says ex-defence secretary Penny Mordaunt

Zelenskyy willing to step down as Ukraine's President 'immediately' if it 'brings peace or Nato membership'

Zelenskyy willing to step down as Ukraine's president 'immediately' if it 'brings peace or Nato membership'

UK Weather, London - 9 February 2020. Storm Ciara brings gale force winds and heavy rain to the London’s West End Theatreland district. Credit: Thamesfleet/Alamy Live News

Fresh amber alert as Met Office issues 'danger to life' warning with UK facing heavy rain and 70mph winds

Homeless asylum seeker starved to death while 'dangling from a London skylight for six days'

Homeless asylum seeker starved to death while 'dangling from skylight for six days'

Destruction in Kryvyi Rih, via The State Emergency Service of Ukraine in Dnipropetrovsk

Russia launches 'aerial terror' on Ukraine, with the biggest drone attack of the war so far