RAF illegally discriminated against white males in bid to boost diversity, inquiry finds

30 June 2023, 06:03 | Updated: 30 June 2023, 07:29

The new RAF chief Sir Richard Knighton has apologised
The new RAF chief Sir Richard Knighton has apologised. Picture: Ministry of Defence
Kieran Kelly

By Kieran Kelly

A Royal Air Force recruitment drive to boost diversity discriminated against white men, an inquiry has found.

Some 161 candidates, who were either women or from ethnic minority backgrounds, were accelerated into training places ahead of other candidates across 2020 and 2021.

The RAF said it accepts the drive amounted to positive discrimination as set out by a Ministry of Defence report, adding it will not "make the same mistakes again".

Former Group Captain Lizzy Nicholl quit her role as head of the drive because she received legal advice which said it was in breach of the Equality Act 2010.

The new head of the RAF Sir Richard Knighton has apologised for the discrimination.

“We now know that it did not, and I apologise unreservedly to all those affected,” he said.

Those who missed out on bonuses due to the discrimination will receive them retrospectively
Those who missed out on bonuses due to the discrimination will receive them retrospectively. Picture: Alamy

Around 31 people were discriminated against that resulting in them not qualifying for a £5,000 bonus.

The RAF has identified these people, who will now be offered the reward retrospectively.

The report said: "We found that concerns were raised at the time by R&S [recruitment and selection] staff but that those who led the initiatives believed that they were 'pushing the boundaries' of positive action rather than acting unlawfully."

It added: "We found that the chain of command's reaction to the former Group Capt R&S was overly defensive and not properly considered whether she might have been justified in what she said regarding previous acts of positive discrimination or the legality of what she was asked to do; and that insufficient effort had been made to determine the facts."

Read More: Moment RAF Typhoons intercept Russian warplanes approaching Estonian airspace in latest tense stand-off in the skies

Read More: Applicants trying to join RAF described as 'useless white male pilots' in push to meet diversity targets

Sir Rich Knighton said in response: "The belief at that time, based on the understanding of the recruiting process and interpretation of the legal advice, was that this practice demonstrated acceptable, positive action. We now know that it did not, and I apologise unreservedly to all those affected.

"We accept that some men were discriminated against. This included a group of 31 individuals, who likely missed the opportunity to qualify for a £5,000 joining bonus. We have identified those people and are retrospectively offering to award them any financial payment they missed out on.

"Those involved in Recruiting and Selection throughout this period acted with the best of intentions; but it is clear that people responsible for implementing these policies did raise concerns at the time, and the way in which long-term aspirational goals set by senior leadership to improve diversity in the RAF were translated into personal performance targets was wrong."

Defence Secretary Ben Wallace, speaking at a press briefing at Canada House in central London on Thursday, said: "The other point to note is that while the whole thing has been, I think, a significant error and indeed a cause for regret for the RAF, they didn't lower the standard.

"They discriminated against those people that were applying (with people) who were above the standard, so our military level wasn't put at risk.

"However, the treatment of the people applying - it was wrong, unsatisfactory."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Jonathan Edge pleaded guilty to offences under the Fraud Act.

Dad jailed for selling 'dodgy Fire Sticks’ to stream Premier League football compared himself to 'Robin Hood'

Pete Hegseth accidentally hit a drummer with an axe

Watch as Trump's new Defence Secretary pick hits drummer with axe on TV

Exclusive
Families of those harmed by the existing ban on assisted dying gather outside Houses of Parliament as the Private Member’s Bill to legalise assisted dying is formally tabled by Kim Leadbeater

Brits want new assisted dying laws to go even further, poll reveals

The Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby has resigned

Abuse is a 'whole church problem' safeguarding lead warns in wake of Archbishop of Canterbury’s resignation

Wes Streeting plans to give the drug to unemployed and obese Brits.

Failing NHS hospitals to be named and shamed as Wes Streeting pledges to sack underperforming managers

The Princess of Wales greets well-wishers after attending the Christmas service at St Mary Magdalene Church, Sandringham.

Christmas boost: Kate's annual carol service will go ahead this year as Princess of Wales reveals special theme

Donald Trump has appointed Elon Musk to his cabinet when he becomes president

Elon Musk to lead US ‘DOGE’ department to cut bureaucracy which they claim will be ‘Manhattan Project of our time’

Donald Trump has appointed Elon Musk to his cabinet when he becomes president

Donald Trump confirms tech billionaire Elon Musk will join cabinet when he becomes president

Shop selling knives in the Old Town in Chania, Crete, Greece.

Social media bosses who don't stop illegal knives being advertised on their sites could face fines

Several sandbags to contain the new flood in Aldaia, Valencia

Flood-hit areas of Spain brace for torrential rain forecast as orange alert issued

Hereford, Herefordshire, UK – Friday 4th July 2024 –

More than half of candidates claim they were abused or intimidated during election campaign

Booker Prize 2024 Award Ceremony in London

Samantha Harvey becomes first woman since 2019 to win Booker Prize

All Main Candidates For PM Address CBI Conference

Victim of serial abuser John Smyth says Archbishop's resignation paves way for others to be held 'accountable'

police uk light car

Three taken to hospital after car mounts pavement on busy London street near Piccadilly Circus

The Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby has resigned

Archbishop of Canterbury only resigned due to ‘immense pressure’, insists John Smyth abuse victim

Andrew Marr spoke to Liz Carr

'Coercion on a state level': Silent Witness star argues assisted dying bill risks people feeling there is 'no choice'