Prince Andrew urged to challenge £10m settlement with sex crime accuser Virginia Giuffre by lawyer she also sued

30 January 2023, 15:21 | Updated: 30 January 2023, 15:25

Prince Andrew should try to overturn the settlement, a lawyer has said
Prince Andrew should try to overturn the settlement, a lawyer has said. Picture: Getty

By Kit Heren

Prince Andrew should challenge his £10 million settlement with Virginia Giuffre, who accused him of sexually assaulting her while she was underage, a lawyer whom she also accused of sex attacks has said.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Alan Dershowitz was accused of sexual assault by Ms Giuffre, but she dropped the claim in November and said she may have made a mistake in his case.

That has reportedly caused the Duke of York to believe her credibility has been undermined and it may be worth challenging the £9.7 million case, which he settled out of court.

Mr Dershowitz told the Telegraph that Andrew should try to get the settlement back, adding that it was a "mistake" not to take the case to trial.

Prince Andrew
Prince Andrew. Picture: Getty

He said: "I have never understood why he accepted the settlement. There were many, many good defences he could have raised. I’ve thought right from the beginning, as soon as the deal was done, it was a mistake to do it.

"He should pursue every legal remedy and the media should investigate thoroughly all of the allegations because this is just the tip of the iceberg.”

Mr Dershowitz, who worked for Jeffrey Epstein in 2008 and has had several other celebrity clients including Donald Trump, added: “I think that the media ought to do a deep investigation to determine the whole truth.

“Everybody should be interested in the truth coming out, the whole truth about everything and it’s very important for the media to start digging deeply into all the allegations and do their due diligence on it … That’s what should be reported, not just one side of the story.”

Virginia Giuffre (R)
Virginia Giuffre (R). Picture: Getty

The case has all but ended Andrew's life in the public eye.

He strenuously maintains his innocence and has not been charged with any crimes. The duke returned his royal and military titles last January after discussions with the Queen.

Read more: Prince Andrew to 'launch £10m legal case' against Virginia Giuffre after 'inheriting millions from the Queen'

Read more: Prince Andrew 'thrown out of Buckingham Palace flat' by King Charles as he's told to stay away

An alleged royal source told The Sun last week: “Andrew has always insisted he is innocent and finally wants to prove it in a US court.

“He was pressured into settling the case to avoid overshadowing the Platinum Jubilee and has paid a heavy price, personally and professionally."

Lucia Osborne-Crowley on Prince Andrew's out of court settlement with Virginia Giuffre.

Andrew's camp has claimed that King Charles supports his bid to reverse the verdict.But the King's advisers have reportedly booted Andrew out of Buckingham Palace and told him to find a new place to live.

US lawyers told the Mirror that Andrew can "forget" about the legal challenge.Lisa Bloom, who represents several of Jeffrey Epstein's victims, said it is "not going to happen".

She said: "Prince Andrew signed his name to a settlement. And now he wants out? Forget it. Not going to happen."Nor should it, because [of] the pain he would inflict on Virginia."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

A firefighter inspects a nightclub after a massive fire in the town of Kocani, North Macedonia, Sunday, March 16, 2025. (AP Photo/Boris Grdanoski)

Arrest warrants issued for four people as North Macedonia nightclub fire death toll rises to 59

Newcombe Road, Coventry.

Double Coventry stabbing kills one and leaves another with 'facial injuries'

Streeting suggests Labour discontent is ‘manufactured rebellion’ as he refuses to confirm disability benefits U-turn

Streeting suggests Labour discontent is ‘manufactured rebellion’ as he refuses to confirm disability benefits U-turn

Alice da Silva Aguiar was one of the three children killed.

Commemorative playground to be built in primary school in honour of Southport victims

Foreign Office staff enjoyed the Nassau Yacht Club in Barbados, in January 2023, spending £920.

Civil servants splurge on Barbados yacht club trip with taxpayer-backed credit card

Met Police sued after reinstating 999 call handler who mock Sarah Everard and called rape victim a ‘slut’

Met Police sued after reinstating 999 call handler who 'mocked Sarah Everard' and called rape victim a ‘slut’

At least 50 dead after fire rips through nightclub in North Macedonia

At least 50 dead after fire rips through nightclub in North Macedonia

FILE - Britain's Prince Harry leaves after attending an Invictus Games Foundation 10th Anniversary Service of Thanksgiving at St Paul's Cathedral in London, Wednesday, May 8, 2024.

Bombshell US court ruling orders Prince Harry's visa application files be made public by Tuesday

This image made from video by NASA shows astronauts waving after the SpaceX capsule docked with the International Space Station, Sunday, March 16, 2025. Top row from left: Nick Hague, Alexander Gorbunov, Suni Williams, Alexei Ovchinin.

Over the moon: SpaceX capsule docks with ISS as stranded NASA astronauts welcome replacement crew

F1 Grand Prix Of Australia

Lando Norris wins a wet Australian Grand Prix despite last minute charge from Max Verstappen

Disabled people to be given right to try working without risk of losing benefits in welfare reforms.

Disabled people to be given 'right to try' work without risk of losing benefits

Britain's Prince William, Patron of the Welsh Rugby Union (WRU), and Kate, the Princess of Wales, Patron of the Rugby Football Union (RFU), pose for a photo with Leif Thobroe

Royal split: William and Kate cheer on rival sides at Wales take on England in Six Nations clash

Wes Streeting MP - Secretary of State for Health and Social Care - in Downing Street 12th March 2025 - the day before NHS England was abolished.

Scrapping NHS England is ‘beginning, not the end’ says Streeting, vowing to cut hundreds of quangos

A view of the pollution caused by garbage and various wastes following the thousands of Palestinians displaced under the ceasefire agreement between Hamas and Israel have returned to the northern Gaza Strip in Jabalia, Gaza on March 13, 2025.

US rejects Hamas’s ‘entirely impractical’ demands to implement ceasefire as talks reach impasse

Antoine Dupont and Gregory Alldritt of France lift the Six Nations Trophy after their team's victory during the Guinness Six Nations 2025 match between France and Scotland at Stade de France

France win Six Nations after beating Scotland, shattering England title hopes

The US has launched large strikes in Yemen as Donald Trump promised "overwhelming lethal force" until the Houthis cease attacks on shipping.

US launches strikes on Yemen as Trump promises 'overwhelming lethal force' against Houthis