Pregnant woman disputes carpool fine saying unborn child counts as person after Roe v Wade

12 July 2022, 23:22 | Updated: 12 July 2022, 23:25

A pregnant woman claimed new US law meant her unborn baby was a passenger
A pregnant woman claimed new US law meant her unborn baby was a passenger. Picture: Alamy

By Daisy Stephens

A pregnant woman in the US who received a fine for driving alone in a carpool lane is arguing that her unborn child counts as a passenger after the Supreme Court's abortion ruling.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The overturning of the landmark Roe v Wade triggered a law in Texas that says an unborn child is a living human from the moment of fertilisation.

Brandy Bottone, who is eight months pregnant, was stopped whilst driving alone in a carpool lane five days after the ruling.

She says she pointed to her baby bump and said: "Well, not trying to throw a political mix here, but with everything going on, this counts as a baby."

Read more: Protests erupt as abortion clinics close across US after Roe v Wade overthrown

Read more: 'Women's lives at risk': Biden blasts 'un-American' US Supreme Court anti-abortion ruling

Ms Bottone did not reveal her thoughts on the ruling, but said she believed it should be applied consistently.

"One law is saying that this is a baby and now he's telling me this baby that's jabbing my ribs is not a baby," said the 32-year-old.

She added: "If there's a pro-women category, that's my stance."

She is challenging the ticket in court next week.

Melissa Mills says women will continue campaigning for abortion rights

Chad Ruback, an attorney in Dallas, told the Washington Post he did not expect her argument to be successful but added she "could find a trial court judge who would award her for her creativity".

Republican state representative Brian Harrison said he plans to introduce legislation to clarify that unborn babies should be treated as passengers.

"Unborn babies are persons (meaning they're also passengers), and should be treated accordingly under Texas laws," he wrote on Twitter.

Shelagh's moving pro-choice explanation of abortion

The US Supreme Court voted to overturn Roe v Wade, a landmark case that gave women across America the federal right to abortion in the first trimester, in June.

Overthrowing the ruling gave states the freedom to ban abortions before 12 weeks if they wish.

Some states including Texas, Alabama, South Dakota and Wisconsin had trigger laws which came into force as soon as the decision was made.

Read more: Trump declares US anti-abortion ruling a decision made by God

Ultimately, the court's overturning of the landmark ruling is likely to lead to abortion bans in roughly half the states.

Of these, 13 outlawed abortion instantly.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Labour MP Chris Webb 'attacked and mugged' near London flat by phone snatching gang

Labour MP Chris Webb 'attacked and mugged' near London flat by phone snatching gang

The White House has been barricaded and restaurants and stores boarded up as tensions rise over the election.

Washington DC braces for unrest as White House is barricaded and stores boarded up ahead of US election

Sir Chris Hoy said 'if you're over the age of 45, go and ask your doctor' for screening

Sir Chris Hoy calls for men to be offered prostate cancer screening from the age of 45 after his terminal diagnosis

Kamala Harris went door-knocking in Pennsylvania on the night before the election

Kamala Harris surprises residents in Pennsylvania as she goes door-knocking in final bid to win votes

Nearly 600 police officers sacked in a year amid as shocking figures reveal extent of misconduct crackdown

Nearly 600 police officers sacked in a year as shocking figures reveal extent of misconduct crackdown

Hundreds of people died in the devastating flooding in Spain

British man who survived Valencia floods describes hearing his neighbours’ horrifying final screams before they died

Amy Dowden said she was ‘heartbroken' as she left this year's Strictly Come Dancing

Amy Dowden says her ‘heart is breaking’ after she confirmed she will not return to Strictly

Anthony Scaramucci said the row between Trump and Labour would blow over

'Anglophile' Trump's row with Starmer will have 'no impact' on wider relations with UK, Anthony Scaramucci says

Nick Ferrari attends his first Trump rally in Pennsylvania as he meets the crowd in 'the poorest city in the United States'

Nick Ferrari attends his first Trump rally in Pennsylvania as he meets the crowd in 'the poorest city in the US'

Exclusive
Nick Ferrari bumps into Nigel Farage in Pennsylvania as he reflects on Trump's "remarkable" foreign policy achievements

Nick Ferrari bumps into Nigel Farage in Pennsylvania as he reflects on Trump's 'near-death' experience

Live
US Presidential Election 2024 LIVE: Millions of Americans head to the polls as election day arrives

US Presidential Election 2024 LIVE: Millions of Americans head to the polls in the final race for the White House

Proud Boys claim they will go to voting places as Trump repeats election fraud lies.

Proud Boys making plans to mobilise as Trump repeats election fraud lies

File photo of a real NHS dentist

Desperate Brits fall for scam 'fake NHS dentists' amid years-long waits for appointments

The Kremlin is suspected of plotting the attack

'Parcel bombs' that blew up in warehouse were 'rehearsal' for Russian explosion attack on flight to US

Keir Starmer is not set to ban smoking in pub gardens, contrary to earlier reports

Cigarettes will not be banned in pub gardens under new Labour plan create 'smoke-free generation'

Former President Donald Trump speaks at a campaign rally in Reading, Pennsylvania

Trump threatens Mexico with 100% tariffs unless it cracks down on border crossings