'Some daft imported ideology': Alex Salmond accuses Sturgeon of damaging Scottish independence push with trans row

7 February 2023, 08:26

Mr Salmond took aim at Ms Sturgeon over her trans stance
Mr Salmond took aim at Ms Sturgeon over her trans stance. Picture: Alamy

By Will Taylor

Nicola Sturgeon has been accused of throwing away years of campaigning for Scottish independence over her stance of trans laws by her predecessor Alex Salmond.

The former first minister said the furore over trans woman Isla Bryson, a rapist with male genitals who was initially sent to a women’s prison, had led to a decline in support for the cause.

Mr Salmond branded the saga as "self-indulgent nonsense", with Mrs Sturgeon engaging in "some daft ideology imported from elsewhere" that "borders on the totally absurd".

A recent YouGov poll put support for independence at 47%, down from 53%, while backing for the SNP at Westminster was on 42%.

Ms Sturgeon wants to treat the next general election as a vote on independence but Mr Salmond said she had hampered that effort with her approach to trans issues.

Speaking at an Alba party Burns supper in Dundee on Saturday – the same weekend the poll came out – Mr Salmond said: "To get to a position where you say to a majority of our people that you cannot have single-sex spaces – prized and worked and strived for – because of some daft ideology imported from elsewhere and, as we’ve seen, imperfectly understood by its proponents in Scotland, borders on the totally absurd.

Read more: 'Perfect in every way': Tributes paid to Lettie, 7, found dead with Epsom College headteacher mother and accountant dad

Mr Salmond took aim at his successor's approach on trans issues
Mr Salmond took aim at his successor's approach on trans issues. Picture: Alamy

"And the six per cent decline in independence vote over a month – think about that.

"Thirty years of gradually building, building, building until we get independence over 50%, and then thrown away with some self-indulgent nonsense, which even if it was right, which it isn't, would hardly be tactically the most astute manoeuvre when we're meant to be taking Scotland to its next date with destiny."

Read more: Specialist diver 'baffled' by Nicola Bulley's disappearance and says he will soon be confident 'she is not there at all'

The row over where Bryson should be held came just after MSPs passed the controversial Gender Recognition Reform bill in Scotland, which makes it easier to officially change gender.

An amendment that would restrict how easy it would be for sex offenders to change gender was narrowly voted down as supporters insisted people do not change their gender on a whim.

Nicola Sturgeon's stance on trans issues has come under fire
Nicola Sturgeon's stance on trans issues has come under fire. Picture: Alamy
Rapist Isla Bryson was initially housed in a female prison
Rapist Isla Bryson was initially housed in a female prison. Picture: Alamy

Bryson was moved to a male prison after an outcry about her being housed in a women's facility. Her estranged wife said he was "bull*******" the system.

The issue has not gone away for Ms Sturgeon, whose approach to tran issues has been both praised and criticised.

"She regards herself a woman, I regard the individual as a rapist," she said in a bid to avoid being challenged over whether she considered Bryson to be a woman.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Pope is 'still in critical condition'

Pope 'still in critical condition' and participated in Holy Mass with carers amid 'complex clinical picture'

Peter Reynolds, 79 and his wife Barbie, 75 have been arrested by the Taliban.

Retired British couple who run education programmes for mothers arrested by Taliban in Afghanistan

Palestinian children and journalists disperse as Israeli tanks enter the Jenin camp for Palestinian refugees in the occupied West Bank, on February 23, 2025.

Israel deploys tanks to Occupied West Bank for first time in two decades as Palestinians 'won't be allowed' to return

The first exit polls show the far-right AfD party will win more than 19% of the vote in Germany, as the conservatives fall short of a majority.

Far-right AfD party wins record 19.2% of the vote in German elections as conservatives set for victory, exit poll shows

Jenny Hall

Body found in search for missing 23-year-old runner Jenny Hall

Long Row, Nottingham.

Boy, 17, stabbed in Nottingham Primark

Former defence secretary Penny Mordaunt told LBC that we must invest more in defence to secure peace in Ukraine.

'We have got to wake up' and spend more on defence, says ex-defence secretary Penny Mordaunt

Zelenskyy willing to step down as Ukraine's President 'immediately' if it 'brings peace or Nato membership'

Zelenskyy willing to step down as Ukraine's president 'immediately' if it 'brings peace or Nato membership'

UK Weather, London - 9 February 2020. Storm Ciara brings gale force winds and heavy rain to the London’s West End Theatreland district. Credit: Thamesfleet/Alamy Live News

Fresh amber alert as Met Office issues 'danger to life' warning with UK facing heavy rain and 70mph winds

Homeless asylum seeker starved to death while 'dangling from a London skylight for six days'

Homeless asylum seeker starved to death while 'dangling from skylight for six days'

Destruction in Kryvyi Rih, via The State Emergency Service of Ukraine in Dnipropetrovsk

Russia launches 'aerial terror' on Ukraine, with the biggest drone attack of the war so far

Krystena Murray, 38, with her baby boy.

Woman sues IVF clinic after being forced to give up baby that wasn't hers, in embryo mix up

Exclusive
Trump a 'useful idiot' to Putin claims ex-security advisor John Bolton, with threats of a 'third term' being taken serious

Trump a 'useful idiot' to Putin claims ex-security advisor John Bolton, with threats of a 'third term' being taken seriously

British Prime Minister Keir Starmer speaks during Scottish Labour Party Conference

Keir Starmer slams Reform UK's 'dangerous right-wing politics' as he accuses Farage of 'fawning over Putin'

Prime Minister Keir Starmer has warned a bad peace deal could be a 'disaster for everyone', as he urged the US to stand by Ukraine on Sunday.

Starmer says UK won’t cave to 'threats and tyranny' as PM warns bad Ukraine deal would be a 'disaster for everyone'

Tram crash Mosley Street Manchester where 3 year old girl was killed. Manchester UK Picture credit garyroberts/worldwidefeatures.com

Police hunt van driver after girl, 3, dies following tram and vehicle crash in Manchester