Meghan Markle wins privacy claim against Mail on Sunday over 'private' letter to father

11 February 2021, 16:10 | Updated: 11 February 2021, 17:26

The Duchess of Sussex has won her High Court privacy claim against the Mail on Sunday
The Duchess of Sussex has won her High Court privacy claim against the Mail on Sunday. Picture: PA
Nick Hardinges

By Nick Hardinges

The Duchess of Sussex has won her High Court privacy claim against the Mail on Sunday over the publication of a "personal and private" handwritten letter to her estranged father, Thomas Markle.

Meghan, 39, sued Associated Newspapers Limited (ANL) - the publisher of The Mail On Sunday and MailOnline - over a series of articles which reproduced parts of the letter sent to 76-year-old Thomas Markle in August 2018.

She took legal action for alleged misuse of private information, copyright infringement and breach of the Data Protection Act over five articles published in February 2019, which included extracts from the letter.

In a ruling on Thursday, Mr Justice Warby granted Meghan "summary judgment" in relation to her claim for misuse of private information, meaning she has won that part of the case without going to trial.

The judge also granted summary judgment in relation to most of the duchess' copyright claim, but said the issue of whether Meghan was "the sole author" of the letter - an issue he said was "of minor significance in the overall context" - should be determined at a trial.

Meghan called her victory a "comprehensive win"
Meghan called her victory a "comprehensive win". Picture: PA

In a statement after the ruling, the duchess said: "After two long years of pursuing litigation, I am grateful to the courts for holding Associated Newspapers and The Mail On Sunday to account for their illegal and dehumanising practices."

She added: "The world needs reliable, fact-checked, high-quality news.

"What The Mail On Sunday and its partner publications do is the opposite.

"We all lose when misinformation sells more than truth, when moral exploitation sells more than decency, and when companies create their business model to profit from people's pain.

"But, for today, with this comprehensive win on both privacy and copyright, we have all won.

"We now know, and hope it creates legal precedent, that you cannot take somebody's privacy and exploit it in a privacy case, as the defendant has blatantly done over the past two years."

A spokesperson for ANL said: "We are very surprised by today's summary judgment and disappointed at being denied the chance to have all the evidence heard and tested in open court at a full trial.

"We are carefully considering the judgment's contents and will decide in due course whether to lodge an appeal."

Court artist sketch by Elizabeth Cook of judge Mr Justice Warby
Court artist sketch by Elizabeth Cook of judge Mr Justice Warby. Picture: PA

Mr Justice Warby said that "the only tenable justification for any such interference was to correct some inaccuracies about the letter", contained in an article in People magazine which featured an interview with five friends of Meghan.

He added: "The inescapable conclusion is that, save to the very limited extent I have identified, the disclosures made were not a necessary or proportionate means of serving that purpose.

"For the most part they did not serve that purpose at all. Taken as a whole the disclosures were manifestly excessive and hence unlawful."

Mr Justice Warby also found that the publication of the letter to Thomas Markle infringed the duchess' copyright.

He said an electronic draft of the letter "would inevitably be held to be the product of intellectual creativity sufficient to render it original in the relevant sense and to confer copyright on its author or authors".

The judge also found that the Mail on Sunday's articles "copied a large and important proportion of the work's original literary content".

But Mr Justice Warby said issues of whether Meghan was "the sole author" - or whether Jason Knauf, formerly communications secretary to the Duke and Duchess of Sussex, was a "co-author" - should be determined at a trial.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Breaking
Kemi Badenoch is the new leader of the Conservative Party

Kemi Badenoch says it is 'enormous honour' to be elected new leader of Conservative Party

Janey Godley has died at the age of 63

Scottish comedian Janey Godley died in hospital 'surrounded by her loved ones' aged of 63 following battle with cancer

Exclusive
Anthony Scaramucci

Anthony Scaramucci says 'garbage' comments made at Trump rally have 'lit up' Puerto Ricans - and could swing election

billy nighy

Billy Nighy 'stole complete works of Shakespeare from library' to prepare for drama school audition

v

Winner in Conservative leadership contest to be announced this morning

Palma is on lockdown amid warnings of heavy rain

Majorca on lockdown as tourist hotspot faces flooding horror after storm kills more than 200

UK GP visiting senior woman at home

Care homes and GPs could face closure under Labour tax plans, health leaders warn

Rebekah Vardy 'threatens to reignite war with Coleen Rooney'

Rebekah Vardy launches appeal against Wagatha Christie £1.8m costs ruling

Alexandra Palace Hosts Its Annual Fireworks Display Ahead Of Bonfire Night

Bonfire night 2024 forecast: What will the weather be like for fireworks night?

Darrian Williams

Two teen boys found guilty after 16-year-old stabbed to death by masked attackers in Bristol park

Westminster Protest

'Betrayed' farmers to protest over Labour's inheritance tax raid - as Chancellor insists changes are 'fair'

The teen was left to die by the side of road.

Six teenagers arrested after 13-year-old girl left with life-threatening injuries in East Yorkshire stabbing

Israel claims to have killed a high-ranking member of Hamas

Israel 'eliminates' one of Hamas' last high-ranking officials

Prince Andrew, Duke of York and Prince Charles, Prince of Wales attend a Service of Thanksgiving to celebrate Queen Elizabeth II's Diamond Jubilee

King Charles 'finally cuts Prince Andrew off' as he 'axes Duke's annual £1m allowance'

Claw hammer-wielding public schoolboy who attacked sleeping students and teacher handed life sentence

Pictured: Public schoolboy, 17, who attacked sleeping students and teacher with hammers he kept 'for zombie apocalypse'

Emergency and rescue personnel work at the site where a concrete outdoor roof of a train station collapsed in the northern Serbian city of Novi Sad

Train station canopy collapses in Serbia, killing 8 people in horror accident, with more victims still trapped in rubble