Litany of failings by probation officers before paedophile rapist Damian Bendall killed four people, watchdog finds

17 January 2023, 02:53 | Updated: 17 January 2023, 06:44

Damien Bendall with his victims
Damien Bendall with his victims. Picture: Derbyshire Police

By Chris Samuel

A watchdog has revealed a litany of failings by probation officers before paedophile rapist Damian Bendall brutally killed four people.

Damien Bendall brutally murdered his pregnant partner Terri Harris, 35, her Lacey Bennett, 11, her son John Paul Bennett, 13, and Lacey's friend Connie Gent, 11 with a clawhammer in Killamarsh, Derbyshire, in September 2021.

Bendall also admitted raping Lacey.

Bendall, now 33, is currently serving a whole-life order for the killings, but a formal review has found that the Probation Service's handling of him was of an "unacceptable standard", and that "critical opportunities" to correct errors had been missed.

Chief inspector of probation Justin Russell said the Probation Service's assessment and management of him, "fell far below what was required", and he was handled by officers who weren't sufficiently qualified and experienced.

Read more: Met Police chief says force will be 'ruthless' in review of 1,000 abuse claims involving officers, after cop admits multiple rapes

Read more: Mum, 17, and baby among six dead after California shooting

Two members of staff faced disciplinary action over the case.

Despite previous convictions for grievous bodily harm and robbery, as well as allegations by a former partner of domestic abuse, Bendall had been put under curfew at home with Ms Harris and her children.

At the time, Bendall was on probation, serving a 24-month suspended sentence for arson.

But no attempt had been made to speak to Ms Harris or visit the property, and there is no evidence that "essential" domestic abuse and child safeguarding checks were done by the probation officers making this decision.

Damian Bendall.
Damian Bendall. Picture: Derbyshire Constabulary

Justice Secretary Dominic Raab ordered a review of how probation staff had supervised the killer when it emerged he had previous convictions for crimes including grievous bodily harm and robbery before the quadruple murder.

Mr Russell's report laid bare a series of missed opportunities by probation officers, including that Bendall's records showed an ex-parter had made allegations of domestic abuse made against him, and that Wiltshire Police's child sexual exploitation unit had contacted probation over concerns about his association with a vulnerable teenage girl in care.

Officers at the time were found to have been focused on Bendall's violence behind bars and extreme right-wing views, rather than the risks he posed at home.

The report blamed inexperience for decisions taken by officers, who "should not have been exposed to cases such as (Bendall's) at this stage in their careers".

Terri Harris
Terri Harris. Picture: Derbyshire Constabulary

Mr Russell said: "If Bendall had been assessed as presenting a higher risk of serious harm - which would have been appropriate - it is unlikely a curfew order would have been deemed suitable and he would have been assigned to more experienced and confident probation officers."

In a statement, prisons and probation minister Damian Hinds said: “These were appalling crimes. The chief probation officer has apologised to the victims’ families for the unacceptable failings in this case and disciplinary action has been taken against two members of staff.”

He added: "The extra funding of £155m a year we have put into the Probation Service is being used to recruit thousands more frontline staff and to ensure domestic abuse and child safeguarding checks are always carried out before any offender is given a curfew.

"The Probation Service has also improved information sharing with police and councils, so no family is put at such significant risk again."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

MP Rosie Duffield claimed she was 'single-handedly bullied' out of the Labour party by 'millionaire barrister' Sir Keir Starmer.

Former Labour MP claims she was 'bullied out of the party' by 'millionaire' Starmer amid 'anti-sleaze' row

Pope Francesco greets the faithful in St. Peter's Square.

Pope facing 'period of trial' as Pontif issues Sunday prayer from hospital

Former advisor to President Putin told LBC ‘Ukrainians will be thankful after we liberate them'.

Putin ally suggests Ukrainians should be 'thankful' nation is being 'bombed to bits'

A firefighter inspects a nightclub after a massive fire in the town of Kocani, North Macedonia, Sunday, March 16, 2025. (AP Photo/Boris Grdanoski)

Arrest warrants issued for four people as North Macedonia nightclub fire death toll rises to 59

Newcombe Road, Coventry.

One man dead and another left with 'potentially life-changing facial injuries' following Coventry double stabbing

Streeting suggests Labour discontent is ‘manufactured rebellion’ as he refuses to confirm disability benefits U-turn

Streeting suggests Labour discontent is ‘manufactured rebellion’ as he refuses to confirm disability benefits U-turn

Alice da Silva Aguiar was one of the three children killed.

Fundraiser for playground in memory of Southport victims Alice da Silva Aguiar and Bebe King reaches £250,000

Foreign Office staff enjoyed the Nassau Yacht Club in Barbados, in January 2023, spending £920.

Civil servants splurge on Barbados yacht club trip with taxpayer-backed credit card

Met Police sued after reinstating 999 call handler who mock Sarah Everard and called rape victim a ‘slut’

Met Police sued after reinstating 999 call handler who 'mocked Sarah Everard' and called rape victim a ‘slut’

At least 50 dead after fire rips through nightclub in North Macedonia

At least 50 dead after fire rips through nightclub in North Macedonia

FILE - Britain's Prince Harry leaves after attending an Invictus Games Foundation 10th Anniversary Service of Thanksgiving at St Paul's Cathedral in London, Wednesday, May 8, 2024.

Bombshell US court ruling orders Prince Harry's visa application files be made public by Tuesday

This image made from video by NASA shows astronauts waving after the SpaceX capsule docked with the International Space Station, Sunday, March 16, 2025. Top row from left: Nick Hague, Alexander Gorbunov, Suni Williams, Alexei Ovchinin.

Over the moon: SpaceX capsule docks with ISS as stranded NASA astronauts welcome replacement crew

F1 Grand Prix Of Australia

Lando Norris wins a wet Australian Grand Prix despite last minute charge from Max Verstappen

Disabled people to be given right to try working without risk of losing benefits in welfare reforms.

Disabled people to be given 'right to try' work without risk of losing benefits

Britain's Prince William, Patron of the Welsh Rugby Union (WRU), and Kate, the Princess of Wales, Patron of the Rugby Football Union (RFU), pose for a photo with Leif Thobroe

Royal split: William and Kate cheer on rival sides at Wales take on England in Six Nations clash

Wes Streeting MP - Secretary of State for Health and Social Care - in Downing Street 12th March 2025 - the day before NHS England was abolished.

Scrapping NHS England is ‘beginning, not the end’ says Streeting, vowing to cut hundreds of quangos