Behaviour of judge who fell asleep during trial ‘amounts to misconduct’ as he apologises amid unremitting workload

30 August 2023, 14:56 | Updated: 30 August 2023, 14:58

The judge was deployed to the north eastern circuit at Sheffield Combined Court.
The judge was deployed to the north eastern circuit at Sheffield Combined Court. Picture: Alamy

By Jenny Medlicott

A judge who fell asleep during a court hearing has been issued with ‘formal advice for misconduct’.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

His Honour Michael Slater, a circuit judge, received the formal advice after it was found his behaviour amounted to misconduct by the Judicial Conduct Investigations Office (JCIO).

It was not disclosed what the ‘formal advice’ he was given said.

The JCIO said judges were expected to show diligence and care carrying out their duties and had to ensure their conduct maintained and enhanced public confidence in their judiciary.

Slater accepted the allegation and apologised - he also addressed the matter with the parties in court and offered them a retrial but they did not take up the offer.

A judge who was nominated to investigate the matter took into consideration Slater’s admission and acknowledged that he had been dealing with the pressure of an ‘unremitting workload’, adding that his behaviour had not derailed the trial.

The lord chief justice and the lord chancellor agreed to issue formal advice to him.

Read more: Hurricane Idalia makes landfall in Florida as DeSantis urges residents to 'hunker down' in face of 'unprecedented' storm

Read more: Royal Family asked Suits creator to 'rewrite script' so Meghan Markle did not have to say 'sensitive' word

Slater was appointed to be a circuit judge in November 2016 and was deployed to the north eastern circuit at Sheffield Combined Court.

And this isn’t the first time a judge has been issued with formal advice for falling asleep in trial.

In 2019, a senior judge in the family division received the same advice after she ‘momentarily’ fell asleep.

The judge “expressed remorse” after she was investigated following a complaint from the parties in the case.

The JCIO said at the time: "While concluding that this amounted to conduct which had the potential to undermine public confidence in the judiciary, the Lord Chancellor and the Lord Chief Justice took into consideration that the judge fell asleep only momentarily and has expressed remorse for doing so."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Piran Ditta Khan has died in jail

Gang boss behind PC Sharon Beshenivsky's murderer dies behind bars months after being locked up

Donald Trump said Zelenskyy and Putin need to 'work together'

Donald Trump says Putin and Zelenskyy 'need to work together' as he denies he's planning 'trip to Moscow'

Salman Rushdie

Man found guilty of attempted murder over Salman Rushdie attack

Diddy's lawyer has quit the sex trafficking case, a New York court heard today

‘I cannot continue’: Sean 'Diddy' Combs' lawyer quits sex trafficking case

Police officers work at the scene where a person was stabbed near the memorial of the murdered jews of Europe in Berlin

Man seriously injured in stabbing at Berlin Holocaust Memorial as police hunt suspect

Kara Alexander, 47, of Dagenham, east London, murdered Elijah Thomas, two, and Marley Thomas, five

Drug addict mother guilty of murdering her two sons then leaving bodies in bunk bed for their dad to find

The hand was found at Our Lady Immaculate school in Darndale

Mystery of ‘severed hand’ found near school in Dublin

The US has held 'positive' talks with Zelenskyy

Ukraine has 'no cards left to play' Trump claims as he slams Starmer for 'doing nothing' to end Russia's war

Pope Francis's doctors say he is 'not out of danger'

Pope Francis ‘not out of danger,’ says doctors who have prescribed ‘absolute rest’

The three brothers have been jailed for dozens of child sex offences

Three brothers jailed for sexually abusing and grooming dozens of young girls in Leeds

iPhone security update.

Urgent warning for iPhone users as Apple to remove highest level of data protection amid government security row

Steve Bannon has been accused of giving a 'Nazi' salute

Donald Trump’s former chief strategist Steve Bannon accused of doing 'Nazi salute' during speech

The US has held 'positive' talks with Zelenskyy

Talks with 'courageous' Zelenskyy were 'extensive and positive', US envoy says just days after Trump dictator comments

Actor Daniel Craig during ' Skyfall ' movie premiere in Berlin on 30th October 2012

Daniel Craig breaks silence after James Bond producers hand franchise to Amazon

Chancellor Rachel Reeves Delivers Speech On Economic Growth

Reeves breaks her fiscal rules and borrows £11.6 billion more than this time last year

Andrew Gwynne, who has said he regrets making 'badly misjudged' comments in a WhatsApp group

Labour MP sacked over vile WhatsApp messages under investigation by Parliamentary watchdog