Government loses High Court bid to prevent Covid inquiry from seeing Boris Johnson’s WhatsApps and diaries

6 July 2023, 15:13 | Updated: 6 July 2023, 15:31

The Cabinet Office has failed to prevent the release of Boris Johnson's messages in the Covid Inquiry.
The Cabinet Office has failed to prevent the release of Boris Johnson's messages in the Covid Inquiry. Picture: Alamy

By Jenny Medlicott

The Cabinet Office has failed to prevent the High Court from releasing Boris Johnson’s unredacted WhatsApp messages and diaries in the Covid inquiry.

Batherness Heather Hallett made an order for the former Prime Minister’s diaries, notebooks and WhatsApp messages to be shared in the Covid inquiry.

However the Cabinet Office sought to block the order, as the department’s lawyers argued ministers could not be forced to release messages that it claimed were “unconnected to the Government’s handling of Covid”.

The department unsuccessfully argued that it should be able to decide what material was “unambiguously irrelevant” in the ongoing inquiry.

However, announcing the ruling on Thursday, Lord Justice Dingemans and Mr Justice Garnham said the Cabinet Office should not be given permission to withhold the messages.

A legal challenge into the matter was launched last week, where both sides made their legal arguments.

High Court announced their decision on Thursday, just six days after the review was launched.

The inquiry’s lead counsel said if the Cabinet was allowed to decide which documents were relevant in the inquiry, it “would emasculate this and future inquiries”.

Lady Hallett, the chairwoman of the Covid Inquiry, also asserted that the Cabinet Office’s argument would have “seriously implications” for the inquiry and “undermine” her ability to carry it out the inquiry properly.

The judgement said: “We therefore dismiss the claim for judicial review but record that the Cabinet Office may respond to the notice by making an application pursuant to section 21(4), that it is unreasonable to produce material which does not relate to a matter in question at the inquiry. It will be for the Chair of the Inquiry to rule on that application."

Read more: Nurse who administered historic Covid jab weeps as NHS is honoured at Westminster Abbey on its 75th anniversary

Read more: 'To forgive, there has to be contrition': Wife of care home Covid-19 victim slams Matt Hancock after inquiry appearance

Read more: George Osborne says 'austerity left Britain better prepared for pandemic' in Covid inquiry appearance

Lady Justice Hallett made the order on the messages.
Lady Justice Hallett made the order on the messages. Picture: Alamy

The Government said it would “comply fully” with the judgement made.

The judges said the the fact the messages would produce “some irrelevant documents” did not “invalidate” its usefulness.

They added if a person: “Contends that a document caught by the request does not, as a matter of fact, relate to a matter in question at the inquiry, it will be for the chair of the inquiry to determine how to deal with such a contention".

Deborah Doyle, spokeswoman for Covid-19 Bereaved Families For Justice UK, said: "This judicial review was a desperate waste of time and money.

"The inquiry needs to get to the facts if the country is to learn lessons that will save lives in the future.

"That means it needs to be able to access all of the evidence, not just what the Cabinet Office wants it to see."

The inquiry chair said they will “return” any documents that “are obviously irrelevant”.

Responding to the judgement, a Government spokesman said: "The inquiry is an important step to learn lessons from the pandemic and the Government is co-operating in the spirit of candour and transparency.

"As this judgment acknowledges, our judicial review application was valid as it raised issues over the application of the Inquiries Act 2005 that have now been clarified.

"The court's judgment is a sensible resolution and will mean that the inquiry chair is able to see the information she may deem relevant, but we can work together to have an arrangement that respects the privacy of individuals and ensures completely irrelevant information is returned and not retained.

"We will comply fully with this judgment and will now work with the inquiry team on the practical arrangements."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Rob and Lindsey Burrow a few weeks before he died

Rob Burrow's wife reveals heartbreaking moment she knew rugby league star 'couldn't go on' with MND struggle

Axel Rudakubana will be 'target number one' in prison

Southport killer Axel Rudakubana's sentence won't be referred to Court of Appeal despite claims it's 'unduly lenient'

The damaged shield

'Risk of radioactive leak' after Russian 'high explosive' drone hits Chernobyl, causing 'significant damage'

The fire broke out at the Chiltern Firehouse

Fire engulfs celebrity haunt Chiltern Firehouse as 100 evacuated from luxury hotel

Trump confirms he will meet Starmer in Washington 'in the next few weeks'

Trump to meet with Starmer in Washington 'in the next few weeks' - as JD Vance slams Europe in fiery speech

Both Meghan and Kate shared Valentine's pictures

Harry and Meghan share sweet Valentine's photo after William and Kate also post romantic picture

Jaden Sheriff.

Man found guilty of killing ex-girlfriend's neighbour over 'blue balls', sentenced to life imprisonment

The woman was attacked by a shark

Horror as woman loses both hands after being mauled by shark as husband desperately fights it off

United States Vice-President JD Vance, second right, meets with Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, third left, during a bilateral meeting on the sidelines of the Munich Security Conference in Munich

'Putin is a liar': Zelenskyy's warning to Trump as Ukraine's leader voices concern over 'risky' phone calls with Russia

Addenbrookes hospital, Cambridge

Children's surgeon suspended after nine operations fall 'below standards' in Cambridge

Lesley Joseph refuses to discuss Pauline Quirke's dementia diagnosis.

'I won't talk about her at the moment': Lesley Joseph refuses to discuss Pauline Quirke's dementia diagnosis

Ada Bikakci

Girl, 9, killed after being hit by London bus, as driver charged with driving while drunk or on drugs

Exclusive
A small group of secondary school pupils working on practical experiments in a chemistry lab.

Ministers should consider shortening school holidays and letting teachers work from home, union chief says

JD Vance

Free speech is 'in retreat' across Europe, claims JD Vance - as US brands it a 'bigger threat than Russia'

oxford street with shoppers

Two arrested in Oxford St 'celebrity romance scam' after victims coerced into sending £200k to 'well-known boyfriends'

What if Ukraine were the UK? Could you accept surrendering a fifth of our country to Putin after so much sacrifice?

What if Ukraine were the UK? Could you accept surrendering a fifth of our country to Putin after so much sacrifice?