Ex-attorney general Geoffrey Cox leads Tory rebellion against PM's Brexit Bill

13 September 2020, 23:23 | Updated: 13 September 2020, 23:55

Geoffrey Cox struck out at the "unconsciable" plan to override the Withdrawal Agreement
Geoffrey Cox struck out at the "unconsciable" plan to override the Withdrawal Agreement. Picture: PA
Nick Hardinges

By Nick Hardinges

Former attorney general Geoffrey Cox has said it would be "unconscionable" for the government to override the Brexit divorce deal.

The Torridge and West Devon MP, who previously served under Prime Minister Boris Johnson in government, is leading the way in the Conservative rebellion against their leader.

He said there is "no doubt" the "unpalatable" implications of the Withdrawal Agreement (WA) would have been known to Mr Johnson when he signed it, a time when Mr Cox was the chief law officer.

The Tory MP said he would not support the UK Internal Market Bill unless the government rules out the possibility of "permanently and unilaterally" rewriting an international agreement that could break the law.

Mr Cox's comments came ahead of the legislation being debated in the Commons on Monday when the Bill is set to return to the chamber amid growing criticism that breaching international law would jeopardise the UK's standing in the world.

The QC, who was attorney general when Mr Johnson's government unlawfully suspended Parliament, said tariffs and customs procedures on certain goods entering Northern Ireland from Britain were part of the deal.

Read more: Boris boost from Starmer - Sir Keir makes key Brexit call

Watch: Brexit Bill is an insurance policy if talks break down, Justice Secretary says

Read more: Justice Secretary 'will quit' if ministers break law in 'unacceptable' way

Robert Buckland: Government still hopeful there will be a deal

"There can be no doubt that these were the known, unpalatable but inescapable, implications of the agreement," he wrote in The Times.

He said if the powers in the legislation were used to "nullify those perfectly plain and foreseeable consequences" then it would amount to the "unilateral abrogation of the treaty obligations" signed in October.

"It is unconscionable that this country, justly famous for its regard for the rule of law around the world, should act in such a way," he said.

The former attorney general urged ministers to use the "clear and lawful" options under the agreement to remedy their concerns that food imports may be blocked from Britain to Northern Ireland.

Or, "in extremis", he said, they could take "temporary and proportionate measures" during an independent arbitration process.

"What ministers should not do, however provoked or frustrated they may feel about an impasse in negotiations, is to take or use powers permanently and unilaterally to rewrite portions of an international agreement into which this country freely entered just a few months ago," he said.

Sumption on 'renegeing' on Brexit agreement

Earlier on Sunday, Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer gave fresh hope to the prime minister's Bill sailing through Parliament, saying he will support the legislation if "substantial concerns" are addressed.

Sir Keir said his party would "play its part" in supporting the UK Internal Market Bill if the prime minister is willing to "fix" a number of cross-party concerns.

Starmer - who will be on LBC from 9am on Monday for Call Keir with Nick Ferrari - still believes a free trade deal can be struck with the European Union if both parties "hunker down in good faith and break the logjam".

However, he also accused Mr Johnson of having "turned the clock back" and of "reigniting old rows" by tabling the legislation that would override parts of his own Withdrawal Agreement.

Also on Sunday, Justice Secretary Robert Buckland said he will resign if the government breaks international law in an "unacceptable" way with the proposed legislation.

However, the minister insisted he does not believe the UK will "get to that stage" and added that the controversial legislation that could break international law was a "break-the-glass-in-emergency provision if we need it".

Sir Roger Gale: Brexit plan 'damaging to the nation'

"If I see the rule of law being broken in a way I find unacceptable then, of course, I will go," he told The Andrew Marr Show on the BBC.

"I don't believe we're going to get to that stage. I know in my mind what I have to do. But the government collectively here also has a responsibility, we've got to resolve any conflict that's what we will do."

However, the chances of negotiating a successful free trade deal is hanging in the balance, with Downing Street's chief negotiator Lord Frost heading to Brussels for informal talks this week.

Mr Johnson warned that the EU could "carve up our country" without his new Bill, as he stepped up his rhetoric as senior Tories prepared to rebel against the legislation.

But outrage at the legislation has come from across the political spectrum, including from Lord Howard and Conservative former prime ministers Theresa May and Sir John Major.

Justice Secretary Robert Buckland on Brexit talks

Sir John and fellow former PM Tony Blair united to urge MPs to reject the "shaming" legislation, saying it imperils the Irish peace process, trade negotiations and the UK's integrity.

"It raises questions that go far beyond the impact on Ireland, the peace process and negotiations for a trade deal - crucial though they are. It questions the very integrity of our nation," they wrote in the Sunday Times.

Despite Mr Johnson's attempts to drum up support, Tory rebels suggested their numbers were growing and opinions were only hardened by the prime minister's increased rhetoric.

The PM, with a large Commons majority, should win an expected vote of the legislation's principles during its second reading on Monday.

But a rebellion could come later with Commons justice committee chairman Sir Bob Neill's amendment, which he said would impose a "parliamentary lock" on any changes to the Withdrawal Agreement.

Labour minister Rachel Reeves said the party would "need to look at the detail" of Sir Bob's amendment and said Labour MPs will table amendments of their own.

She told the Marr show that Labour will vote against the government's Bill if it still contains clauses overriding the WA.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Israel has launched the largest strikes on Gaza since the ceasefire agreement with Hamas, killing and injuring dozens while promising 'increasing military force'.

Israel launches 'extensive' deadly strikes on Gaza, which Hamas says indicate 'unilateral end to ceasefire'

Badenoch is expected to drop the party’s commitment to net zero, which the UK is legally required to reach by 2050, in a speech on Tuesday.

UK net zero target by 2050 is ‘impossible’ without bankrupting Britain, says Kemi Badenoch

John ‘Paddy’ Hemingway, the last surviving pilot that served in the Battle of Britain, has passed away at the age of 105.

Last surviving Battle of Britain pilot John ‘Paddy’ Hemingway dies aged 105

A selection of credit cards in a fan.

Almost 20,000 Civil Service credit cards to be frozen in government plans to halve number of cards and cut spending

MPs have been urged to support moves to ban smacking and other forms of physical punishment against children in England.

Ministers urged to back law change which will see smacking children to punish them banned

Polling station at Deptford Park School.

Russian networks tried to disrupt UK election but did not cause ‘notable’ impact, security minister says

IKEA store in Vilnius, Lithuania

Russian spies accused of firebombing Ikea store ‘because colours are the same as the Ukraine flag’

Facial recognition will be used to help passengers skip passport queues at ports.

British travellers arriving back in UK could 'avoid passport queues' with new facial recognition technology

The White House said Trump is ‘determined’ to get a peace deal in Ukraine over the line, as the US president gears up for talks for Vladimir Putin on Tuesday.

‘We’ve never been closer to a peace deal’ in Ukraine, says White House ahead of Trump-Putin talks

A prison officer walks down the C wing at Wandsworth prison.

Number of prisoners reaches six-month high, despite thousands being released early to ease overcrowding

Richard Burrows, 80, was found guilty of 54 offences at Chester Crown Court on Monday, including indecent assault of boys, buggery, attempted buggery and indecency with a child.

Paedophile scout leader who spent 27 years on the run found guilty of dozens child sex abuse crimes

‘Iran will suffer the consequences’ - Trump raises prospect of war with Iran as Us attacks on Houthis continue

‘Iran will suffer the consequences’ - Trump raises prospect of war with Iran as US attacks on Houthis continue

Owen Cooper (l) and Stephen Graham (r) star in Adolescence

Revealed: Secret behind incredible camera shot in Netflix's new 'masterpiece' Adolescence

Drag star The Vivienne died after taking ketamine, their family said today

Drag star The Vivienne died from cardiac arrest caused by taking ketamine, family say

Irish professional mixed martial artist and businessman Conor McGregor visited the White House on Monday.

‘He doesn’t reflect the spirit of St Patrick’s Day’: Row erupts after Conor McGregor appears in The White House

`

Man who shouted 'Die, die, die' while stabbing man in quiet street in broad daylight sentenced to life