Bishops blame ministers for creating 'boom market' for small boats migrant traffickers

1 July 2023, 18:03 | Updated: 1 July 2023, 18:05

Justin Welby has previously said the government's Rwanda plan 'does not stand the judgment of God'
Justin Welby has previously said the government's Rwanda plan 'does not stand the judgment of God'. Picture: Getty

By Adam Solomons

Church of England bishops have blamed the government for the small boats crisis, claiming ministers are creating 'perverse incentives' for criminal traffickers.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

In a briefing paper for MPs seen by the Mail on Sunday, the Church's Mission and Public Affairs Council wrote that the government's pledge to stop the boats fails to recognise "human dignity".

The bishops added in a submission to the House of Commons' Home Affairs committee: "The increasing securitisation makes the routes by sea riskier, and the profits for traffickers correspondingly higher.

"Far from creating deterrence, the UK’s approach is creating a boom market for criminal enterprises."

The Church of England's latest intervention comes days after the government's Rwanda plan was ruled unlawful by the Court of Appeal.

Read more: Stop the boats? How Andrew Marr would tackle the migrant crisis

Read more: Rwanda plan will be 'money well spent' if it 'makes it less attractive' for migrants crossing the Channel, minister says

Home Secretary Suella Braverman is pictured during a visit to Rwanda in March
Home Secretary Suella Braverman is pictured during a visit to Rwanda in March. Picture: Getty

Senior judges ruled that Rwanda is not a 'safe country' to receive asylum seekers from the UK.

The nation has been criticised for its human rights record, which include crackdowns on the government's political opponents, so-called "enforced disappearances" and members of the LGBT community.

The House of Lords is currently considering Rishi Sunak's Illegal Migration Bill, which states that all migrants arriving by "irregular means" can be forcibly removed to Rwanda to have their asylum claims processed.

If successful, asylum seekers will be offered permanent residency in the central African country, with no option to return to the UK.

Labour will discard Tory Rwanda deportation plan says Shadow Trade Secretary

Archbishop of Canterbury Justin Welby has said the Rwanda plan is 'ungodly'.

In his Easter address last year, the Church's most senior clergyman said: "Let Christ prevail. Let the darkness of war be banished.

"And this season is also why there are such serious ethical questions about sending asylum seekers overseas.

"The details are for politics. The principle must stand the judgment of God, and it cannot."

Rwanda is not 'free or safe country' for refugees says Chair of United Democratic Forces of Rwanda

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Weeks’ worth of rubbish has piled up on the streets across Birmingham.

Birmingham declares major incident over bin strikes as 17,000 tonnes of rubbish piles up and rats run riot

Jeffrey Epstein sex-trafficking victim who claimed Prince Andrew sexually abused her given 'four days to live' by doctors

Jeffrey Epstein victim and Prince Andrew accuser issues fresh statement after being given 'four days to live'

Former GCHQ staff member, Hasaan Arshad, leaving the Old Bailey.

Former GCHQ intern admits taking top secret data home in risk to national security

President of the far-right Rassemblement National (RN) parliamentary group Marine Le Pen

French far-right leader Marine Le Pen vows to fight election ban after embezzlement conviction

President Donald Trump and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth

White House says 'Signal chat case is closed' insisting issue has been 'dealt with'

Gary Glitter facing bankruptcy after paedophile refuses to pay damages to victim he raped when she was 12

Gary Glitter facing bankruptcy after paedophile refuses to pay damages to victim he raped when she was 12

ustice Secretary Shabana Mahmood

Sentencing Council to delay 'two-tier' guidelines after backlash

A Taliban security personnel stands guard.

Taliban ask Russia to lift ban on terrorist organisation

Exclusive
British Prime Minister Kier Starmer holds a roundtable meeting at Number 10 Downing Street in London, Monday March 31, 2025. (Jack Taylor/Pool Photo via AP)

Sir Keir Starmer suggests to LBC people who abused student visas to come to UK could face deportation

Britain's Prime Minister Keir Starmer (L) shakes hands with Finland's President Alexander Stubb

'The UK is back': Finnish president praises Starmer's leadership announcing two nations are 'tied hip-to-hip on Nato'

Aerial photograph of London City Airport looking towards Canary Wharf

'Extensive search' operation underway after girl, 11, falls into River Thames

Weeks’ worth of rubbish has piled up on the streets across Birmingham.

City council declares 'major incident' after Birmingham bin strikes cause chaos amid mounting rubbish piles

Passengers arriving at the Gare du Nord, Paris on a Eurostar train from St. Pancras, London; Gare du Nord train station, Paris France

Eurostar rivals 'given the green light' to run trains through Channel Tunnel

A woman who was discovered in the River Mersey last year has been identified through extensive investigation - including facial reconstruction technology.

Family pays tribute to mum identified by facial reconstruction a year after body found in River Mersey

Club house covered in red paint as members of group Palestine action caused damage to the Trump owned site of Trump Turnberry Golf Club in Scotland.

Man, 33, appears in court accused of maliciously damaging Donald Trump's Turnberry golf course

Fifteen Palestinian paramedics and rescue workers have been discovered in a mass grave

Fifteen Palestinian paramedics and rescue workers killed 'one by one' by Israeli forces - as mass grave discovered