Chris Packham wins libel case against two men over false tiger donation accusations

25 May 2023, 13:28

Chris Packham won the court case agains two men, while a third claim was dismissed
Chris Packham won the court case agains two men, while a third claim was dismissed. Picture: Alamy

By Will Taylor

Springwatch star Chris Packham has won a High Court libel case over claims he misled the public into donating to a wildlife charity so "broken" tigers could be rescued from circuses.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

The presenter sued three men for libel over nine articles which said he had "manipulated" people into donating to save five tigers but knew the animals were being looked after.

He strongly denied the claims, which were also repeated in tweets and videos, about his involvement with the Wildheart Trust, which runs a sanctuary on the Isle of Wight.

The editor of online site Country Squire Magazine, Dominic Wightman, defended the claim with writer Nigel Bean and a third man, Paul Read.

Mr Justice Saini ruled in favour of Mr Packham's claims against Mr Wightman and Mr Bean on Thursday, but dismissed the claim against Mr Read.

"Mr Packham did not commit any acts of fraud or dishonesty," he ruled.

He wrote in his judgement: "In short, Mr Packham did not lie and each of his own statements was made with a genuine belief in its truth.

Listen and subscribe to Unprecedented: Inside Downing Street on Global Player

Mr Packham won his libel claims against two men
Mr Packham won his libel claims against two men. Picture: Alamy

"There was no fraud of any type committed by him in making the fundraising statements."

The two men will have to pay £90,000 in damages to Mr Packham.

Speaking outside court, Mr Packham said: "Every day many thousands of innocent people are victims of online abuse and hate crimes.

Read more: 'Devil Baby' Mason Mount stalker made '£50k from eating Percy Pigs naked' and was banned for dancing in Asda aisle

"This can be racially, religiously or politically motivated. It can be generated in regard to gender politics, environmental beliefs, body shaming.

"This vile part of modern life ruins lives, livelihoods, reputations, it disrupts young peoples' educations, causes incalculable mental health problems and tragically causes people to take their own lives.

"As it stands the criminal law is simply not there to protect us from such hate - something that must change.

Chris Packham won his claims against two people who edit or write on an online title
Chris Packham won his claims against two people who edit or write on an online title. Picture: Alamy

"The current governments 'Online Safety Bill' is plodding along. In the meantime a tiny minority of victims are able to take civil action."

The judge said Mr Wightman and Mr Bean failed to come "even close to establishing the substantial truth" of the allegation Mr Packham defrauded anyone over the tigers.

"They did not merely allege in the publications that there was some lack of care or negligence on the part of Mr Packham when he made statements about where the tigers had come from or as to their earlier lives," he said.

"Nor did they suggest merely a careless lack of precision by Mr Packham in which he stated or implied the tigers were being kept in cramped conditions... (they) went straight for the most serious allegations of actual fraud and dishonesty."

"However, the agenda adopted by [Mr Wightman and Mr Bean] meant that they approached what might be facts suggesting, at the very highest, that questions might be asked about the accuracy of the fundraising statements, as proving fraud and dishonesty on the part of Mr Packham."

The judge went on: "Any investigative journalism quickly gave way, in the fifth and following articles, to increasingly hyperbolic and vitriolic smearing of Mr Packham, with further unsubstantiated allegations of dishonesty regarding peat-burning and the trust's insurance gratuitously thrown in."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

ynthia Erivo attends the EE BAFTA Film Awards 2025 at The Royal Festival Hall on February 16, 2025 in London, England.

Stars stun on the red carpet at 2025 BAFTAs

The head of Ofsted said children in England feel going to school is optional since the pandemic, as their parents opt to work from home instead of going to the office.

Parents working from home makes kids not want to go to school, Ofsted chief says

Oleksandr Zinchenko of Arsenal arrives at Molinuex

Millionaire Premier League star earning £150k a week loses HMRC court battle over hundreds of thousands in unpaid tax

Actress Kim Sae-ron attends 2017 Mnet Asian Music Awards at Asia World-Expo on December 1, 2017 in Hong Kong, Hong Kong.

South Korean ‘Bloodhounds’ and ‘The Man from Nowhere’ star Kim Sae-ron found dead at 24

Emergency services were called just after 7pm on Friday amid reports a woman had suffered serious injuries

'Screaming, shouting, crying': Landlady breaks silence after woman shot dead at village pub - as manhunt continues

Exclusive
Jonathan Reynolds told LBC’s Iain Dale that NATO is ‘a highly effective integrated defensive structure’, and that US requests for higher European spending on the alliance are ‘not unreasonable’.

Europe must ‘work closely’ with US to face Russia, Business Sec tells LBC ahead of emergency Ukraine summit

.T. Miller #10 of Team USA and Colton Parayko #55 of Team Canada fight during the first period in the 4 Nations Face-Off game at the Bell Centre on February 15, 2025

Gloves off: Three fights in first nine seconds as USA beat Canada to reach 4 Nations ice hockey final

Exclusive
Europe must boost defence spending if it wants peace, Ukraine's former PM has told LBC.

‘If you want peace, pay for it', says ex-Ukrainian PM as Starmer to 'overrule' Reeves and boost defence spending

Lucy Letby was ‘shocked and distressed’ during the investigation into the deaths of babies that she was later found guilty of murdering, and ‘deserves an Oscar’ if she was lying, her former boss said.

Lucy Letby was 'innocent', distressed and ‘deserves an Oscar if she was acting’ says former boss

Jockey Michael O'Sullivan at Ascot Racecourse. Picture date: Friday November 22, 2024.

Cheltenham-winning jockey Michael O'Sullivan dies aged just 24 after fall in race

Prime Minister Keir Starmer Meets With Chancellor of the Exchequer Rachel Reeves At Downing Street

Starmer to 'overrule' Reeves and call for increased defence spending ahead of meeting with Donald Trump

images shared on social media show police arresting a man following the attack.

'Laughing' Syrian asylum seeker who stabbed boy, 14, to death was motivated by 'Islamic terrorism'

Axel Rudakubana has been jailed for 52 years.

FBI joins investigation into Southport killer amid claims he wiped internet search history

Heavy Rush In Trains For Last Amrit Snan On Prayagraj Kumbh

At least 15 dead in train station stampede in New Delhi

Pope Francis Attends The Weekly General Audience on Wednesday.

Pope Francis to miss Sunday prayer due to 'absolute rest' order after bronchitis diagnosis

Udoka Godwin-Malife

Burton Albion defender allegedly target of racist abuse by fan