Terminally ill people 'may be able to end their lives without judge's approval' under assisted dying

29 January 2025, 23:37 | Updated: 30 January 2025, 00:39

Supporters of the Assisted Dying Bill last year
Supporters of the Assisted Dying Bill last year. Picture: Alamy

By Kit Heren

Terminally ill people may be able to take their own lives without a judge's approval under the assisted dying proposals currently being scrutinised - after warnings that courts could be overwhelmed.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Lawyers and judges have warned that the current wording of the Bill, which requires each case to be approved by a High Court judge as well as two separate doctors, could overload the legal system.

The need for a judge to sign off on each assisted dying incidence was one of the key safeguards in the legislation, which was voted through by MPs in its second reading last year. The Bill is currently being scrutinised in its committee stage.

Ms Leadbeater has described hers as the only Bill in the world with "three layers of scrutiny" in the form of sign-off by two doctors as well as the High Court judge.

If the legislation were passed in its current form it would require some 34,000 hours of judicial involvement each year, according to an analysis - significantly higher than current capacity.

Read more: Chris Whitty says assisted dying could come in within two years but warns it shouldn't be rushed

Read more: Why are women in their twenties opting for assisted dying in the Netherlands? LBC went to find out

Kim Leadbeater, who is spearheading the Bill
Kim Leadbeater, who is spearheading the Bill. Picture: Alamy

Some have also said that a panel of experts such as psychiatrists and social workers would be better suited to approving assisted dying cases than a judge.

Former Supreme Court judge Jonathan Sumption told MPs on the Bill committee he disagreed with the inclusion of the need for High Court approval.

Giving evidence on Wednesday, he described the High Court approval aspect as "unnecessary and in some respects undesirable", suggesting it is "not entirely clear what the the judge is supposed to do".

He said: "Is he there in order to ensure that the two doctors have done their job and that the ducks are all there in a row, or is he there to form his own view on all of those matters, completely independently of those who have already given their certificates?"

He added that he believed what has been presented as an extra layer of scrutiny in fact "confers a protection which is largely illusory".

Doctor says we must 'sort out' palliative care sector before looking at assisted dying

While agreeing with the principle of assisted dying, Lord Sumption has previously described Kim Leadbeater's Bill as "seriously defective", "over-engineered, bureaucratic, and coldly inhumane".

Lord Sumption also said he is in favour of the principle behind the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill but warned of the limitations when it comes to safeguards to protect people from coercion.

Under the proposed Bill it would be illegal for someone to pressure, coerce or use dishonesty to get someone to make a declaration that they wish to end their life or to induce someone to self-administer an approved substance.

The committee heard from Dr Lewis Graham, a law fellow at Cambridge University, who said the Bill as it stands contains "more safeguards than some of the other legislation in European countries, and the legislation in those countries has been held to be compatible with the right to life, with other rights under the European Convention".

He added: "So from a pure human rights perspective, which is all I feel qualified to comment upon, I think you're in very safe grounds."

Labour MP warns of doctors suggesting assisted dying to patients

Lord Sumption, who sat in the Supreme Court for six years until 2018, agreed, but added: "I think we must all be conscious of the fact that coercion, even when it is overtly applied, is extraordinarily difficult to detect."

He said: "We have to live with the limitations of what human beings can do. So that in the end, I have come down in favour of the principle behind this Bill, but I regard it as an extremely difficult balance to draw, notably for that reason."

Fazilet Hadi, head of policy at Disability Rights UK, said the Bill - which they are opposed to - must be looked at in the context of disparities in wealth, social care, palliative care and general healthcare which already exist.

She told MPs: "When we're looking at inequalities, I think we do need to note that this Bill is going to be plunged into a society that has deep, entrenched health inequalities that don't play out well for people who are poorer."

She said she could not suggest any way in which the Bill cold be strengthened because "the society it will land in is the thing that needs to change, not the Bill".

She added: "At the moment, there's very little likelihood of that society becoming more equal, having better public services, having less health inequality in the next few years."

Baroness Kishwer Falkner, chairwoman of the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC), told MPs that while the organisation is neutral on assisted dying, she believed there are "important and serious considerations" regarding various rights and how they might be affected by the Bill.

Jonathan Sumption
Jonathan Sumption. Picture: Alamy

These include the right to freedom from inhuman and degrading treatment, and freedom of religion under the European Convention on Human Rights.

She indicated there are outstanding issues around the definition of terminally ill, capacity, coercion and whether judges might have exemptions from the process on conscientious grounds.

Responding to Baroness Falkner's call for an impact assessment of the Bill, health minister Stephen Kinnock confirmed - as stated last week in Parliament - that one will be published before the legislation reaches report stage in April.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Breaking
Breaking News

Pope Francis' weekend engagements cancelled as hospital stay extended

Breaking
Bristol, UK. 19th Mar, 2020. Petrol now under £1 a litre as the drop in oil prices hits the forecourt. 99.9p a litre at Costco, Avonmouth, Bristol. Credit: Julian Kemp/Alamy Live News

Ten people injured after 'noxious substance' thrown in Costco as police hold teenage suspect

Heartbreak as Brit pensioner, 90, 'starves to death in her Spanish home' as son, 63, 'found dead in property'

Heartbreak as Brit pensioner, 90, 'starves to death in her Spanish home' as son, 63, 'found dead in property'

E-scooters are currently illegal to use on the public highways including pavements.

E-scooters blamed for 'shocking' surge in uninsured teen riders with 2,000% increase in offences

Breaking
Thames Water has won court approval for a £3 billion emergency debt package as the nation's biggest water company scrambles to avoid collapse.

Thames Water handed £3 billion lifeline as court approves restructuring plans to save it from financial collapse

US and Russia begin talks about Ukraine in Saudi Arabia

US-Russia talks begin in Saudi Arabia as Starmer faces Europe backlash over Ukraine peacekeeping plans

A drone view of Everton's new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock during an Everton under-18 friendly match test event.

Everton's new stadium makes it's grand debut after £800million and four years

Job Centre Plus, London Road, Twickenham, Greater London, England, Great Britain, United Kingdom UK, Europe

UK wages see unexpected rise as unemployment rate holds steady at 4.4 per cent

Placebo band leader Brian Molko has been charged with defamation for calling the Italian PM a fascist and a Nazi during a gig.

British rock star Brian Molko charged after 'calling Italian PM a piece of s*** fascist and a Nazi' during gig

Exclusive
Short sentences and recall periods are keeping offenders in a longer cycle of going to jail, LBC has heard.

'It sent me back to square one': Short sentences create endless cycle of jail time, inmates tell LBC

Shocking footage shows passenger's 'lucky escape' after Delta jet crashes and 'flips' at Toronto airport leaving 18 injured

Shocking footage shows passenger's 'lucky escape' after Delta jet crashes and 'flips' at Toronto airport with 18 injured

Cracks over Starmer’s 'premature' peacekeeping plan as Europe left ‘irritated’ following crisis summit

Cracks over Starmer’s 'premature' peacekeeping plan as Europe left ‘irritated’ following crisis summit

The woman was attacked by a shark

Family of woman whose hands were bitten off by shark reveal 'nightmare' after husband fought off '7ft' predator

Renée Zellweger

Mad about the Box Office: Latest Bridget Jones installment smashes rom com record

Exclusive
David Gauke wants to reduce the size of the female prison estate to make room for more male inmates. File image shows Pentonville prison

Send fewer women to jail to make room for male inmates, says former Justice Secretary

x

Starmer will ensure UK is 'leading country' as European nations step up in support of Ukraine