Gender-neutral toilet deemed 'favourable' to men as judge rules council discriminated against female clerk

3 February 2023, 08:55

Earl Shilton Council in Leicestershire was found to have discriminated against Ms Miller
Earl Shilton Council in Leicestershire was found to have discriminated against Ms Miller. Picture: LBC / Alamy

By Danielle DeWolfe

A judge has ruled a town council sexually discriminated against a female clerk after a men's bathroom was turned into a makeshift gender neutral toilet.

First brought to court in 2020, Karen Miller initially won her discrimination claim against Earl Shilton Council in Leicestershire before the council appealed the decision.

Problems began when Ms Miller was asked to post a makeshift gender-neutral sign on the door of the men's toilet when she went in to use it at the council's offices.

Upon entering, the bathroom's single toilet cubicle was located at the back of the restroom, with women required to walk past a urinal in order to gain access to it.

The council also failed to provide a sanitary bin until the issue was flagged by Ms Miller.

Stock Image. Earl Shilton Council in Leicestershire was found to have discriminated against Ms Miller
Stock Image. Earl Shilton Council in Leicestershire was found to have discriminated against Ms Miller. Picture: LBC / Alamy

Judge James Tayler said the facilities weren't adequate because of the lack of a sanitary bins and probability of coming across a man at the urinal.

He added: "That treatment was less favourable than that accorded to men.

"A woman being at risk of seeing a man using the urinals is obviously not the same as the risk of a man seeing another man using the urinals.

"The claimant was not provided with toilet facilities that were adequate to her needs, because of the risk of coming across a man using the urinal and the lack of a sanitary bin."

Read more: Fury as British Airways pilots and cabin crew 'banned from posting cockpit selfies' on social media

Read more: Jockey Club scraps 'outdated' formal dress code to make racing more 'accessible and inclusive'

The council's appeal has now been rejected by the Employment Appeal Tribunal.

The judge added: "No woman or girl should have to walk past the urinals to get to the toilet, and no man should have the risk of women walking past.

"Even in the smallest of buildings it is possible to have decent facilities, and in larger buildings providing ladies, gents and a unisex option in separate rooms mean that everyone is catered for."

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Pep Guardiola, Manager of Manchester City

Pep Guardiola signs two-year contract extension with Manchester City

Captain Tom's Daughter Hannah Ingram-Moore

Behaviour at Captain Tom charity left ex-boss 'gobsmacked'

Armed robbers attempted to break into the star's Sunderland home.

Masked machete-wielding robbers break into Charlotte Crosby's home while she is upstairs with two-year-old daughter

Police have released new CCTV of Harshita Brella and her husband

Chilling CCTV released of Harshita Brella and prime murder suspect husband on night she was killed

First photos of Gavin and Stacey Christmas Special as James Corden and Ruth Jones mark triumphant finale

First photos of Gavin and Stacey Christmas Special as James Corden and Ruth Jones mark show's triumphant finale

King Charles performs a Hongi, a traditional Maori greeting, with Mere Takoko

King Charles shares traditional Maori nose rub greeting with activist as he launches environmental charity

Putin issued a chilling threat to the West as he confirmed Russia launched a ballistic missile against Ukraine

Putin issues chilling warning to UK and US as he confirms Russia hit Ukraine with new 'experimental' ballistic missile

Telegraph writer Allison Pearson.

Police drop investigation into journalist Allison Pearson over tweet - as review to be launched over handling of case

Exclusive
Angela Rayner has paid tribute to John Prescott

Angela Rayner says John Prescott 'used to call her after PMQs to remind her to stay true to who she is'

Four men have been arrested accused of attempting to rob a mobile phone store

Undercover police arrest four men after EE shop raided by masked gang

Matt Gaetz withdraws as Donald Trump's nominee for attorney general amid sexual misconduct allegations

Matt Gaetz withdraws as Donald Trump's nominee for attorney general amid sexual misconduct allegations

Donald Trump Watches SpaceX Launch Its Sixth Test Flight Of Starship Spacecraft

Elon Musk pledges to fire civil servants who work from home

Seven-month-old baby mauled to death by family dog after leaning on animal while crawling, inquest hears

Seven-month-old baby mauled to death by family dog sustained 'catastrophic' injuries after leaning on pet, inquest hears

Starmer has backed the International Criminal Court over its arrest warrant for Netanyahu

Starmer backs International Criminal Court after it issues arrest warrant for Benjamin Netanyahu

Five men charged over smuggling of migrants from UK to France in lorries

Five men charged over smuggling of migrants from UK to France in lorries following dawn raids

Rhiannon Skye Whyte was stabbed to death in Walsall

South Sudanese teen accused of murdering asylum seeker hotel worker with screwdriver 'refuses to appear in court'