Mushroom poison murder suspect pleads not guilty as she makes huge decision over trial

7 May 2024, 08:20

Erin Patterson, 49 (L) has been charged with murder. Don and Gail Patterson died after eating the beef wellington
Erin Patterson, 49 (L) has been charged with murder. Don and Gail Patterson died after eating the beef wellington. Picture: Social Media

By Emma Soteriou

A woman accused of serving her ex-husband's parents and an aunt poisonous mushrooms with lunch has made a huge decision over her trial after pleading not guilty.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Erin Patterson, 49, is accused of killing her former parents-in-law, Don and Gail Patterson, both 70, and Gail Patterson's sister, Heather Wilkinson, 66.

All three died in a hospital days after consuming a meal at Patterson's home in July last year.

She is also charged with five counts of attempted murder, according to court documents.

Patterson's case is being fast-tracked, with her going straight to a jury trial after deciding not to continue her bid to hold a preliminary hearing at a local court.

Read more: Mushroom poison murder suspect makes special request from behind bars in second court appearance

Read more: Mushroom poison murder suspect ‘threw freedom party’ day before she was charged with killing three people

Don and Gail Patterson died after eating the beef wellington
Don and Gail Patterson died after eating the beef wellington. Picture: Social Media

It comes after she previously requested her criminal proceedings continue to be held in Victoria, meaning she faced an extended wait in custody.

Magistrate Tim Walsh previously said he would not be able to have the preliminary hearing this year due to the court being fully booked.

However, barrister Colin Mandy, SC, who is representing Patterson in court, said it had been a direct request from her and that she was willing to wait longer behind bars until she can get a court date.

Mr Mandy said: "She would like to have her committal hearing heard in your honour's court, in her local community, and she's content to wait until the court can accommodate her."

"Does she understand it's unlikely to be this year?" Mr Walsh said. 

Mr Mandy responded: "We anticipated the court might be able to accommodate us at that period, in that window we flagged with your honour, but if it's the next year then Ms Patterson is content to wait.

"Which puts her in custody for 14 or 15 months... at the least."

Patterson was expected to have a three-week preliminary hearing before her case moved forward. 

Her ex-husband was thought to have been among the witnesses planned to be called at the hearing.

The Supreme Court is now expected to next hear Patterson's case on May 23, with her currently being held at a women's prison.

More Latest News

See more More Latest News

Iran

Official says rescuers see helicopter that was carrying Iran’s president

Taiwan President

Lai Ching-te inaugurated as Taiwan’s president which will likely bolster US ties

Rescue teams’ vehicles are seen near the site of the incident of the helicopter carrying Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi in Varzaghan in north-western Iran

Helicopter carrying Iran’s president apparently crashes in mountainous region

The "real-life" Martha from Netflix's Baby Reindeer bombarded Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer with a vile 276 email spree over eight months, reports claim.

Real-life Martha from Baby Reindeer bombarded Keir Starmer with vile email spree, reports claim

Rachel Reeves has said Rishi Sunak and Jeremy Hunt are gaslighting Brits over the economy - as Labour analysis claims high inflation has cost workers almost the equivalent of a 1p hike in tax.

Reeves accuses Sunak of gaslighting Britain on economy as research claims Inflation 'costs UK same as 1% tax hike'

Prime Minister Rishi Sunak is set to offer the first government apology for the infected blood scandal as the public inquiry into the disaster publishes its final report.

Sunak set to apologise for infected blood scandal which killed 3,000 as inquiry publishes report

Iran's president is missing after a helicopter he was travelling in crashed - with sources in Tehran warning his life is in danger.

Pictured: Iranian president's helicopter taking off just moments before crash in adverse weather

File photo dated 16/10/13 of HMP Barlinnie in Glasgow. The Scottish Government has been accused of moving at a 'snail's pace' in refreshing the prison suicide prevention strategy. The documen

'Up to 23,000 criminals each year to avoid jail' if Government loosens sentences as prisons fill up

Pep Guardiola has hailed his history-making Manchester City side but admitted his future at the club is in doubt after his sixth top-flight win.

'It's insane': Pep Guardiola hails Manchester City record-breakers as side wins fourth Premier League in a row

Iran's President Ebrahim Raisi is feared dead after his helicopter crashed in the repressive nation's north-west.

Who is Ebrahim Raisi?: Iran's President nicknamed 'The Butcher of Tehran' feared dead after helicopter crash

The helicopter carrying Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi takes off at the Iranian border with Azerbaijan after President Raisi and his Azeri counterpart Ilham Aliyev inaugurated dam of Qiz Qalasi, or C

What we know so far about incident involving helicopter carrying Iran president

Sean "Diddy" Combs has broken his silence and apologized after a distressing video was shared of him physically assaulting his former girlfriend Cassie in 2016.

'I'm disgusted': Sean 'Diddy' Combs breaks silence on shocking footage of him physically assaulting ex

Producer-director-writer John Krasinski attends the premiere of Paramount Pictures’ IF at the SVA Theatre in New York

John Krasinski’s IF hits box office nerve with £27.5m North American debut

Kinshasa

Democratic Republic of Congo’s army says it foiled coup attempt

Flowers are placed outside the FD Roosevelt University Hospital, where Slovak Prime Minister Robert Fico is being treated, in Banska Bystrica, central Slovakia

Slovakia PM Robert Fico remains in serious condition but prognosis ‘positive’

The number of small boats arriving in the UK is 2,600 higher than this time last year

Number of migrants arriving in UK in small boats nears 10,000 - 2,600 higher than this time last year